Estates and Trusts Law Blog
Estates and Trusts
Estate Planning for the Newly Divorced Woman: A Critical Step Toward Your Future
Divorce is an emotional and often life-changing experience, regardless of whether it is amicable or contentious. For many women, especially those who have been married for years, it can feel like stepping into the unknown. As a newly divorced person, you may find yourself grappling with a whirlwind of financial, emotional, and logistical challenges. One crucial aspect that often gets overlooked during this transitional period is estate planning. After a divorce, the financial landscape shifts dramatically, necessitating an urgent need to review and potentially restructure your estate plan. Whether you had an estate plan in place during your marriage or are considering one for the first time, having a proper plan is essential to safeguard your assets, protect your children, and secure your future. Suffice it to say estate planning should be a top priority for newly divorced women. Update Your Will and Trust: Control Over Your Legacy During your marriage, your Last Will and Testament or Revocable Trust likely reflected decisions made with your former spouse in mind. After a divorce, these documents require a comprehensive overhaul. One immediate change to consider is removing your former spouse as a beneficiary unless there are specific legal obligations, such as alimony or child support, that necessitate their inclusion. Additionally, if you have children, your prior will may have named guardians for them. In light of your changed family structure, consider appointing different trustees for the funds you intend to leave to your children. While your former spouse retains certain rights as a biological parent, your estate plan allows you to designate who will manage your children's inheritance if something were to happen to you. Change Beneficiaries on Life Insurance and Retirement Accounts It is imperative to change the beneficiaries on life insurance policies, retirement accounts (such as IRAs and 401(k)s), and any other accounts where your former spouse is named. Accounts with designated beneficiaries pass directly to the listed beneficiary, bypassing the terms of your Will or Trust. Failing to update this information may result in your former spouse receiving these funds, regardless of your divorce. Many mistakenly assume that their divorce automatically revokes outdated beneficiary designations; however, this is not always the case. To ensure your assets are allocated to the correct beneficiaries, update these designations immediately. Consult your matrimonial attorney before making changes if your divorce is not yet final, as restrictions may apply. Revisit Powers of Attorney and Health Care Proxies An often-overlooked aspect of estate planning post-divorce is updating your powers of attorney (POA) and health care proxies. If your former spouse was named to make financial or medical decisions on your behalf, this designation should be revisited. While some states automatically revoke these fiduciary appointments upon divorce, others do not. Depending on your state, failing to update these documents could allow your former spouse to control your medical decisions and finances during a vulnerable time. Taking charge of this now is one of the most empowering steps you can take toward your newfound independence. Even if your state automatically revokes a former spouse’s right to act as a fiduciary under a POA or a health care proxy, it is imperative that you have a successor to act in your former spouse’s stead. As with any fiduciary role, you must appoint someone you trust: whether it is a family member, a close friend, or an adult child, someone should be appointed to handle these responsibilities should you become incapacitated. Planning for Your Children’s Future Divorce significantly impacts your minor children’s future—emotionally, financially, and legally. Although your former spouse retains certain financial and custodial rights, you can use your estate plan to specify your wishes regarding their upbringing and financial care. Consider establishing a trust for your children to ensure their inheritance is managed responsibly by someone you trust, particularly if you have concerns about your former spouse’s financial management. Appoint a trustee who will oversee the disbursements to your children over time, even if your former spouse is their guardian. Post-divorce is also a good time to reassess your life insurance needs. You may need additional coverage to ensure that your children are well provided for in the event of your passing, especially if you are the primary caregiver or breadwinner post-divorce. Protect Your Assets and Build a New Financial Legacy It is well-known that divorce has a disparate financial impact on women versus their spouses. Divorce often leaves the divorced woman in a starkly different financial position than what she had during her marriage. You may now own a home solely in your name, with the bills to match. Proper estate planning and consultation with a trusted financial planner provide you with knowledge and control over how these assets are distributed when the time comes. Proper planning provides a platform for you to rebuild and protect your financial legacy for the future. If your spouse previously managed the family finances, it is not uncommon to feel uncertain about your financial independence. Even if you were the primary financial manager, your current financial landscape may differ significantly from what it was during your marriage. Working with an estate planning attorney and a trusted financial advisor will help you get organize your finances, understand your current standing, and plan for long-term security. Moving Forward with Confidence Divorce marks the end of one chapter while opening the door to new beginnings. Though the process can be overwhelming, estate planning is an essential tool that offers clarity and control. By taking proactive steps now, you can ensure that your assets, loved ones, and legacy are protected as you embark on this new phase of your life. Partnering with a trusted estate planning attorney will guide you through this process, allowing you to focus on rebuilding your life with confidence. You have the power to shape your future, and estate planning is one of the most empowering steps you can take.
October 28, 2024
Elder Law and Advocacy
Elder Abuse Exposed: Understanding the Crisis and Lessons from Stan Lee’s Story
Elder abuse is a widespread issue that impacts millions of elderly individuals worldwide. It often manifests in different forms, including physical abuse, emotional or psychological mistreatment, neglect, and, most commonly, financial exploitation. Vulnerable older adults—particularly those experiencing cognitive decline, frailty, or social isolation—are particularly at risk. Among the most high-profile cases of elder abuse in recent years involves Stan Lee, the legendary creator of Marvel Comics. Understanding Elder Abuse Elder abuse can happen anywhere, including in homes, nursing facilities, or even public spaces. A common factor among these cases is that the abuser is generally someone trusted by the elder, such as caregivers, significant others, or family members. In fact, statistics reflect that nearly 60% of financial abuse is committed by a spouse, significant other, or family member. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), one in six people aged 60 and older has experienced some form of abuse in community settings within the past year. The actual numbers are likely much higher, as many cases of elder abuse go unreported due to fear or shame. Stan Lee: A Victim of Elder Abuse Stan Lee, the co-creator of iconic superheroes like Spider-Man, the X-Men, the Avengers, and many other beloved superheroes, passed away in 2018 at the age of 95. His final years were overshadowed by a deeply troubling elder abuse scandal. After losing his wife and advocate of 70 years, Lee's physical and mental health deteriorated significantly, leaving him increasingly dependent on others to manage his personal, financial, and creative affairs. Allegations emerged that Lee fell victim to financial and emotional abuse at the hands of his former business manager, who had become a trusted confidant. As with most elder abuse cases, the manager allegedly isolated Lee from his family and longtime associates, seized control of his finances, misappropriated millions in assets, coerced him into public appearances, and restricted access to family members and those who had supported Lee for decades. Furthermore, this manager even relocated Lee into a new home without informing his only child. The Financial Exploitation of Elders Lee's case is not an isolated incident; financial exploitation is the most common form of elder abuse. While Lee's situation is noteworthy due to the unusual occurrence of financial exploitation among wealthy individuals with significant assets, elders of all economic backgrounds—especially those with diminished mental capacity—are at risk of manipulation and exploitation. In Lee's case, the exploitation was particularly egregious, given his status as a global pop culture icon with a multimillion-dollar estate. Although Lee experienced rapid exploitation within a year following his wife's death, most financial abuse unfolds slowly and subtly. It is important to keep in mind that this financial abuse can manifest as forgery, coercion in managing finances under the guise of assistance, or through more sophisticated and deceptive schemes involving multiple perpetrators. Sadly, statistics indicate that abuse and exploitation disproportionately affect elders with more modest means—those least equipped to handle economic setbacks in their later years. Alarmingly, nonwhite elders are particularly vulnerable, with reports showing they are 200% more likely to suffer from elder abuse compared to their white counterparts. Legal Protections and Reporting Cases like Lee's illustrate the urgent need for improved legal protections and reporting mechanisms for elder abuse. Although laws aimed at combating elder abuse exist, enforcement is frequently lacking. Most elderly individuals lack the capacity to seek help, which is often what makes them vulnerable in the first place. Alarmingly, those who might normally report such abuse are often perpetrators themselves. These factors, combined with the shame and fear associated with reporting, severely hinder the prosecution of these crimes. While many elder abuse units exist within law enforcement, significant gaps remain in the system due to a lack of resources and, from my perspective, a lack of empathy for senior victims. What We Can Learn from Stan Lee's Story The tragic story of Stan Lee's elder abuse serves as a powerful reminder that even the most celebrated individuals can fall victim to exploitation in their later years. It underscores the critical need for planning ahead and vigilance from both loved ones and legal authorities to protect vulnerable elders from abuse. For those caring for elderly loved ones, staying engaged, monitoring financial activities, and advocating for their well-being is essential. Preparation for potential incapacity can also help prevent victimization. Aging loved ones should have the proper legal documentation in place, such as a Power of Attorney and Trust instruments, which empower them to designate trusted individuals prior to their incapacity. Proper legal authority and the appointment of reliable individuals in positions of trust reduce the risk of exploitation by bad actors. Preparing for potential incapacity can also help prevent victimization. Aging loved ones should have essential legal documentation in place, such as a Power of Attorney and Trust instruments, which empower them to designate trusted individuals before they become incapacitated. Proper legal authority and the selection of reliable individuals in positions of trust reduce the risk of exploitation by bad actors. Despite the flashy headlines of Mr. Lee's case, elder abuse remains a largely hidden crisis. Greater societal acknowledgment of its existence, coupled with stronger legal protections, will better ensure that our elderly population can live with dignity and security. Protecting elders from exploitation is a moral imperative that requires collective awareness, legal guidance, and action. Whether famous or not, senior adults deserve respect, care, and protection in the twilight of their lives, allowing them to age with dignity.
October 2, 2024
Estates and Trusts
The Estate Planning Benefits of Marriage: What Unmarried Couples Need to Know
It is becoming increasingly commonplace for people to enter long-term romantic relationships without legally marrying. While there are no exact statistics on how many Americans fall into this growing category, a 2019 Pew Research Center study estimated that 12% of Millennials were living with an unmarried partner, compared to 8% of Gen Xers—an increase of 50% from one generation to the next. While this trend is influenced by various social and political factors, many of these couples may not fully appreciate the extensive economic and legal benefits they forgo by remaining unmarried to their partner. In fact, over 1,000 federal laws provide legal benefits and privileges to married couples. It is beyond this article's scope to discuss every way in which the law favors married couples. Rather, this article will highlight just a few of the many estate planning benefits and opportunities that are conferred on married couples that are not shared by unmarried couples. As I will illustrate, often with little planning, married couples can defer, reduce, or completely eliminate taxes. Unlimited Marital Deduction - Lifetime Gifting Any gift exceeding the annual gift tax exclusion amount, which in 2024 is $18,000 per donor per recipient, is a taxable gift that must be reported by filing a gift tax return (IRS Form 709). However, there is a very significant exception to this rule. One spouse may convey to the other spouse an unlimited amount of assets at any time and as often as desired without incurring any gift tax liability. This creates many estate planning opportunities. As just one example, married couples can strategically retitle assets between each other to maximize the “step-up” in the capital tax basis that these assets receive at death. The “step-up” means that any appreciation in an asset from when the decedent first acquired it gets wiped away at death, and the recipient receives the asset with an adjusted capital tax basis as of the decedent’s date of death. Thus, married couples can convey assets to each other so that upon the death of the first spouse, the surviving spouse receives highly appreciated assets with a one-half or even full step-up, saving significant capital gains taxes when the asset is later sold. Unlimited Marital Deduction – Inheritance The unlimited marital deduction also applies to transfers between spouses at death, shielding the surviving spouse’s inheritance from any estate taxes. This powerful tool allows the surviving spouse to defer the payment of any estate taxes resulting from the first spouse's death for their entire lifetime. This gives the surviving spouse time to spend down or gift these assets to minimize or eliminate estate tax liability for their future heirs at the time of their death. The unlimited marital deduction is also key to “by-pass” trust planning, a technique that ensures that no estate taxes are owed at the death of the first spouse while maximizing the use of their estate tax exemption. By-pass trust planning works as follows: upon the first spouse’s death, two trusts are established for the surviving spouse’s benefit. One trust is funded with assets up to the estate tax exemption amount, allowing these assets to continue to appreciate outside the surviving spouse’s estate. When the surviving spouse passes away, this trust terminates, and the assets are distributed to the ultimate beneficiaries free of estate tax. The second trust is funded with the remaining estate assets and is structured to take advantage of the unlimited marital deduction. Portability A spouse may claim the deceased spouse’s unused exemption (DSUE) for their later use via a concept known as portability. To claim the DSUE of the deceased spouse, the surviving spouse must timely file a federal estate tax return (IRS Form 706). Unlike a “bypass” trust plan, portability requires no advanced estate planning and incurs no administrative costs or inconvenience. Regardless of any subsequent changes in the law, the DSUE will be available for the surviving spouse to benefit from in their estate. With the current estate tax exemption amount at a historical high, it is a particularly advantageous time to file an estate tax return solely for portability purposes. Those intending to rely on portability planning should be cautious, as the surviving spouse cannot claim any unused state estate tax exemption amount. Therefore, portability planning may be sufficient for residents of New Jersey, which abolished its estate tax in 2018, but it may not be adequate for residents of New York, which has an estate tax. Unused generation-skipping transfer tax exemption amounts are also not portable between spouses. Inheritance Tax For New Jersey residents, an inheritance tax is imposed on certain classes of recipients of a decedent’s estate assets. The surviving spouse, a Class “A” beneficiary, is wholly exempt from inheritance tax liability. For those married clients who wish to provide an inheritance for beneficiaries in a class that would be subject to the inheritance tax, making lifetime gifts outright or in an irrevocable trust remains a valid strategy for avoiding the inheritance tax. Inherited IRAs Before the enactment of the SECURE Act, beneficiaries of inherited IRAs were permitted to take required minimum distributions (RMDs) based on their life expectancy. A beneficiary younger than the original account owner would have much smaller RMDs, allowing the IRA assets to appreciate over a long period of time income tax deferred. The SECURE Act largely eliminated this strategy. Under current law, most beneficiaries must liquidate their inherited IRA within ten (10) years of the death of the original account holder. The SECURE Act carved out an exception to this rule; it allowed those deemed an “eligible designated beneficiary” (“EDB”) to take RMDs based on their life expectancy. Among the limited categories of EDBs, you guessed it, the surviving spouse is deemed an EDB. A husband or wife who outlives their spouse for many years could see these assets significantly appreciate over their lifetime. Moreover, the surviving spouse has significantly more flexibility in taking withdrawals above the RMD in years when the assets will be taxed at lower marginal income tax rates. Challenges for Unmarried Couples The flip side to all the planning opportunities available to the married couple is that the unmarried couple cannot benefit from any of them. Any gifts between the unmarried couple above the annual exclusion amount would be taxable. Unmarried couples who receive the inheritance of their deceased partner’s estate may be subject to estate taxes, significantly reducing the assets that the surviving partner would otherwise have available for their support. In New Jersey, in addition to any estate tax liability, a non-married surviving partner may be subject to inheritance tax liability. Lastly, the surviving partner may not be an EDB; thus, they will need to withdraw the entire amount of the IRA within ten years, potentially losing out on years of further appreciation. Of course, the unmarried couple still needs estate planning. Indeed, if an unmarried person were to die without preparing a will or trust, the intestacy laws of most states would direct their assets automatically to children, parents, or siblings. There are also tax planning techniques available for the unmarried couple to reduce estate taxes, such as the establishment of one or more lifetime irrevocable trusts. This kind of planning, however, is more expensive, and the administration is costly and burdensome. State legislatures have taken some meaningful steps to protect the rights of unmarried couples in recent years. For example, both New York and New Jersey recognize domestic partnerships, a legal arrangement that confers some of the benefits afforded to married couples on unmarried couples. For example, a domestic partner in New Jersey is a Class “A” beneficiary, exempt from inheritance tax. However, most tax planning opportunities available to married couples remain unavailable to domestic partners. I am hopeful that future legislatures will address some of these disparities, particularly as the unmarried share of the population continues to grow. However, until that legislative fix occurs, sometimes the best planning advice for an unmarried couple in a long-term relationship is to change their marital status.
September 24, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Protecting Your Legacy: Trust and Estate Planning for Musicians
Understanding how to protect and transfer these invaluable assets can ensure that a musician's creative legacy endures and continues to benefit future generations. Embarking on the journey of music copyrights and estate planning is like composing a symphony of legal and financial strategies for musicians and their heirs. Unlike many professions, a music career brings a distinct set of legal and financial challenges, making it crucial for artists to manage their legacies with care. Given the unpredictable nature of the music industry and the substantial value of intellectual property (IP) assets, having a solid plan is not just advisable—it’s essential. Understanding how to protect and transfer these invaluable assets can ensure that a musician’s creative legacy endures and continues to benefit future generations. One of the most important things musicians must pay attention to is their IP rights. It’s important to recognize that with music copyrights there can be multiple copyrights involved in a single song, including the copyright of the composition and the lyrics if they were composed with a partner and separately from the score. So, there are a lot of moving parts to track with a musical piece. Understanding the basics of music copyright is essential before delving into estate planning. A copyright is a collection of legal rights initially owned by the author, including the right to perform the work publicly. These rights are treated like other intangible assets and can be owned jointly, held in trust, or transferred by gift or at death. Properly inventorying and valuing your music copyrights is a critical first step in estate planning. A qualified appraiser can help determine the worth of these assets by examining their income history or market value, which aids in evaluating estate planning options and predicting potential gifts or estate taxes. Ensuring that copyrights for compositions and recordings are registered correctly and that proper powers are provided to trusted successors is key to a portfolio, inheritance, and a comprehensive estate plan. For example, assigning these rights to a trust is an excellent way to provide ongoing income to beneficiaries. Musicians must also account for how royalties should be managed and distributed. This can involve setting up trusts specifically for royalty income. One idea is for musicians to set up management companies to handle their IP assets that can provide continuity and professional management of the musician’s works after death. Let’s take a lesson from Taylor Swift. The key lesson is to protect yourself early. Swift owned the composition of her music; however, she didn’t own the master recordings, and they were purchased without her blessing. To remedy that, Swift famously and with fanfare re-recorded her songs to secure rights to master recordings for most of her catalog. Musicians must also carefully consider who will oversee monetizing their music and brand after they die. Who do they want to decide how their image is used, whether their songs can be used in movies or TV shows, or whether they want to be a hologram? Musicians often have dependents, such as children or elderly parents, who rely on their income. Like many who pass without advance planning or an estate plan, a musician’s assets may go through probate, a time-consuming and public process. Estate planning tools like trusts can help avoid probate, ensuring a smoother transition for heirs and provide for these dependents long-term. Estate planning for musicians also involves navigating complex tax issues, especially when significant estates that may be subject to federal and state estate taxes are involved. Proper planning, including using trusts and charitable donations, can help mitigate these taxes. Beneficiaries may have to pay taxes on royalties and other income from the musician’s IP. Structuring the estate to minimize these taxes is crucial. Musicians making substantial gifts during their lifetime should be aware of potential gift tax implications. Key Legal Instruments in Estate Planning Several legal instruments are crucial in the estate planning process for musicians: Wills: A will is a foundational document in estate planning that outlines how a musician’s assets should be distributed upon death. A will provides for the distribution of property you own at the time of your death. This can include your instruments, gear, and assets related to your music career. You can also designate who will be responsible for managing your music and other intellectual property after your passing. Generally, you may gift your property in any manner you choose. However, wills must go through probate, which can be avoided with other tools. Trusts: A trust is a legal arrangement that allows you to transfer ownership of your assets to a trustee, who can manage those assets for the benefit of your beneficiaries. This can be a useful for musicians to ensure that their loved ones are taken care of after their passing. Trusts are flexible tools that can manage and distribute a musician’s assets according to specific instructions. They can be beneficial for managing ongoing royalty streams and providing for dependents. Of importance for artists is how the handling of the intangible assets known as digital assets are managed post-mortem. These are issues properly handled in an estate plan. In a comprehensive estate plan, there can be multiple trust structures for planning and gifting. Revocable Trusts: A trust created during one’s lifetime may be revocable. Like it suggests, this means it may be revoked or changed by the settlor (“Introduction to Wills—American Bar Association”). These trusts allow musicians to retain control over their assets during one’s lifetime and provide instructions for distribution after death. Irrevocable Trusts: An irrevocable trust means it cannot be revoked or changed by the settlor. This is useful in gifting strategies for artists considering their taxable estate. Health Care Power of Attorney: You have the right to decide who can make decisions about your health care. These documents allow musicians to designate someone to make healthcare decisions on their behalf and outline their instruction for medical treatment if they become unable to communicate. It is not only important to create an estate plan for musicians, but also critical that the estate plan is kept up to date. Things change, mangers change, people get divorced, and children get added, as do grandchildren. Perhaps the person who was first designated as the manager of the estate is out of the picture. It is essential to keep the estate plan up to date as circumstances change, and to make sure that family is aware of updates. In the world of music, where creativity and complexity blend, trust and estate planning strike the right chords for crafting a lasting legacy. By partnering with legal experts who understand the intricacies of intellectual property and the unique needs of entertainers, musicians can craft a plan that not only safeguards their legacy but also ensures their artistic vision endures. This thoughtful approach transforms a vibrant career into a timeless legacy, preserving the essence of their contributions for future generations. Reprinted with permission from the September 10, 2024, issue of The Recorder. © 2024 ALM Media Properties, LLC.
September 18, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Navigating NIL Deals: Why Estate Planning is Essential for College Athletes
As September brings students back to school across the country, college athletes are encountering new opportunities and challenges, particularly with the recent developments in Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) rights. Now able to leverage their personal brand as a valuable commodity while competing at the collegiate level, athletes face a paradigm shift that requires financial literacy and strategic planning. This transformation has turned student-athletes into potential entrepreneurs, with their talents and popularity becoming marketable assets. One crucial element of a strategic plan that is often overlooked is estate planning, which can protect a student-athlete’s newly acquired assets and ensure long-term financial security. The NIL “Revolution” The National Collegiate Athletics Association’s (NCAA) decision to allow athletes to profit from their NIL rights has opened a significant and long-overdue financial door for college athletes. Now, they can capitalize on endorsement deals, social media partnerships, and even personal business ventures during their college careers rather than waiting for professional opportunities to unlock financial rewards. However, with these new earnings come added complexity. For young athletes, rapidly growing income and brand recognition introduce significant financial and legal considerations. Estate planning—often thought of as something for older individuals—becomes crucial for these athletes to manage their wealth, mitigate taxes, and ensure long-term security. Estate planning involves organizing how assets will be managed and distributed in the event of incapacitation or death. It typically includes creating wills, trusts, powers of attorney, healthcare directives, and implementing tax strategies. For college athletes, however, estate planning is not just about planning for life after death—it is about protecting assets, managing new income, and ensuring their families and loved ones are cared for in case of the unexpected. Why Should the College Athletes Plan Ahead? Asset Protection: NIL deals can yield substantial income, with earnings likely to increase as an athlete’s career progresses. A comprehensive estate plan helps protect this wealth from creditors, lawsuits, and other risks. Trusts, for instance, can provide a layer of legal protection, ensuring that the newfound fame and exposure do not lead to financial vulnerability. Trusts can also facilitate smooth transfers in the event of incapacity. Tax Efficiency: Significant earnings from NIL deals can result in hefty tax liabilities. An estate plan can implement strategies to reduce tax exposure during an athlete’s career, into retirement, and beyond. Since tax laws vary by state, working with an expert can help athletes navigate complex tax requirements and avoid overpaying. Disability Planning: In high-contact sports like football, soccer, or basketball, the risk of injury is always present. Estate planning can include provisions for medical or financial decision-making in case of incapacitation due to injury. This ensures that a trusted individual is in place to manage the athlete’s financial affairs and act in their best interests, even if they are unable to make decisions themselves. Brand Management: For student-athletes whose personal brand significantly contributes to their earnings, estate planning can safeguard their image, likeness, and business ventures, even after their retirement. A well-structured trust or corporate entity can hold and manage these rights, ensuring that the athlete’s brand remains protected and managed according to their wishes. The Foundational Elements of an Athlete’s Plan Last Will and Testament: The cornerstone of any estate plan. It outlines how assets should be distributed and designates guardians for any dependents, ensuring that loved ones and interests are cared for according to the athlete’s wishes. Trusts: Offer flexible tools for asset protection, tax planning, and managing income over time. They help avoid probate, reduce tax burdens, protect trust assets from potential lawsuits, and provide tailored terms for beneficiaries. Power of Attorney: This document grants a trusted individual the authority to make financial and legal decisions on behalf of the athlete if they become incapacitated or even if the athlete is unavailable due to in-season travel, ensuring that important matters are handled effectively in their absence. Healthcare Directives: These directives detail medical care and treatment preferences and designate someone to make healthcare preferences and appoint someone to make healthcare decisions if the athlete is unable to do so due to injury or illness. This ensures that their medical treatment aligns with their wishes. Business and Brand Succession Planning: For athletes with substantial earnings from NIL deals, succession planning is crucial. This includes strategies for protecting intellectual property, trademarks, or businesses tied to their name and image. Proper planning ensures their brand and business ventures are preserved and managed in alignment with their long-term goals, even after death, to ensure that their loved ones reap the benefit of their brand well into the future. The Importance of Estate Planning in the NIL Era In the fast-paced and often unpredictable world of college sports, estate planning provides student-athletes and their families with a crucial safety net. As NIL deals continue to grow in both value and complexity, so too does the need for thoughtful estate management. Estate planning equips athletes with the tools to protect their assets, preserve their brand, and ensure their legacy both on and off the field. For any college athlete navigating the new NIL landscape, estate planning is not just a financial strategy but a pathway to long-term security and peace of mind for themselves and their loved ones. If you or your family are navigating the opportunities and challenges of NIL agreements, it’s worth considering a conversation with someone who understands both the legal and financial landscape. Candace Dellacona is available to discuss how estate planning can fit into your broader financial strategy, ensuring you’re prepared for the future.
September 17, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Writing Your Own Epilogue: How Estate Planning Can Shape Your Legacy
William Shakespeare said, “A good play needs no epilogue.” When a story is compellingly told, in other words, there is no need for commentary after the curtain falls. Like a play that is well written, a life that is well lived speaks for itself. But living well includes knowing that you have planned for what happens after you are gone. This foresight includes how easily your estate will be passed down to the people you care about. Have you written a will that names someone to settle your estate? If something were to happen to you, do you know who would receive your assets? If you have children, have you appointed a guardian to look after them and a trustee to manage their inheritance? If not, the commentary on your life could well include tales of confused intentions and mismanaged assets, of hurt feelings and squandered wealth. Fortunately, all it takes is a phone call to an estates and trusts attorney to make your epilogue your own. With your guidance, the attorney can prepare your will, durable power of attorney, and advance medical directive. These essential documents name a cast of characters who can take charge if you should die or become incapacitated. Your Last Will and Testament names a “personal representative,” or executor, who will administer your estate. Dying without a will, or “intestate,” would require someone to step into this role. The person they select could be an estranged sibling or disapproving parent, who will then have the legal authority to go through your home and distribute your possessions and other assets to your heirs. By preparing a will, you ensure that the right person is in charge of settling your affairs. Writing a will also enables you to leave your assets to the people you select. Shakespeare himself did this when he bequeathed his “second-best bed” to his wife. In addition to your spouse or partner and any children, you might consider including a charitable organization, such as an alma mater or house of worship, among your beneficiaries. Working with an attorney is an opportunity to coordinate assets like life insurance and retirement accounts with the provisions in your will. These “non-probate” assets are not controlled by your will and instead transfer directly to the named beneficiary upon your death. It’s essential, then, that these beneficiary designations work in tandem your will and are not at odds with it. Even a well-lived life can include periods of struggle. If you ever become incapacitated, a durable power of attorney can name someone you trust to manage your finances. The duties of your “attorney in fact,” as the person is called, could include paying your bills, filing your taxes, or even selling your house in order to move you into assisted living. An advance medical directive is like a power of attorney but relates to your health care. It enables you to state your wishes for managing an end-of-life illness and to name a trusted individual who will ensure that your wishes are carried out. If you lose capacity and don’t have an advance directive, the authority to make medical decisions on your behalf will fall to your next of kin. Surprisingly, this could be several people, like a group of siblings, who could have very different ideas about how to manage your care. By preparing an advance directive, you can instead name someone with your best interests at heart to take on this essential role. Of all the benefits of having an estate plan, perhaps the greatest is the reassurance of knowing that the actors you have chosen are prepared to step into their roles when the need arises. With that in mind, when is the best time to have your estate-planning documents drawn up? As Shakespeare said in the Merry Wives of Windsor, “Better three hours too soon than a minute too late.” Lee Carpenter is a Principal at the law firm of Offit Kurman, P.A., and can be reached at (410) 209-6426 or lee.carpenter@offitkurman.com. This article is intended to provide general information and should not be construed as legal advice.
September 3, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Corporate Transparency Act Reporting for Covered Entities Owned by Trusts
We are now six months into the new compliance regime instituted by the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) and practitioners should be aware of the reporting obligations to assist clients with required disclosures. This article limits its focus to trusts. Specifically, estate planners should be able to advise their clients as to which parties to a trust need to report under the CTA when a trust owns business interests. Reporting Requirements Effective January 1, 2024, the CTA requires that “reporting companies”[1] disclose to the US Department of the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) certain information about the company including, but not limited to, its beneficial owners. Trusts themselves generally are not considered reporting companies because the CTA only applies to entities created by filing an organizational document with a state authority such as a secretary of state; however, when a trust owns interests in a reporting company, all parties associated with the trust may be considered beneficial owners of the reporting company. The CTA defines a beneficial owner as any individual who either: (1) exercises substantial control over a reporting company, or (2) owns or controls at least 25 percent of a reporting company’s ownership interests.[2] Individuals can substantially control or own a reporting company through trust arrangements. Substantial control is broadly defined[3], and there is no limit to the number of individuals associated with a trust who may need to be reported for exercising substantial control, and thus considered a “beneficial owner.” Given the far-reaching meaning of substantial control, any number of individuals that may constitute a beneficial owner with respect to a trust, including the trustee, beneficiary, grantor, or other individuals such as trust protectors, distribution trustees or advisors, investment trustees or advisors, members of the trust protector committee, holders of a power of appointment, or other power holders, whether directly or indirectly through contracts, arrangements, understandings, relationships, or otherwise. If a trust owns or controls at least 25 percent of a reporting company’s ownership interests or exercises substantial control over a reporting company, then the parties to the trust that meet the following conditions are considered beneficial owners and must provide beneficial ownership information to FinCEN: Any party to the trust who: Has authority to vote 25 percent or more of the interests of the reporting company. Has authority to dispose of trust assets. Has authority to remove and replace trustees or direct investments. Is the sole permissible recipient of trust income and principal. Has the right to demand a distribution. Has the right to withdraw substantially all of the trust assets. Has the right to otherwise control the trust’s activities. Has the right to revoke the trust or withdraw trust assets. Has the right to swap assets with the trust and reacquire assets from the trust. Once it is determined who is a beneficial owner, such parties must furnish to the reporting company their full legal name, date of birth, residential address, and an identification number from a driver’s license, passport, or other state-issued identification along with a copy of the identification document. Any time this information changes, the reporting must be updated. Corporate Trustees If the beneficial owner is a legal entity such as a corporate trustee, the reporting company should determine whether any of the corporate trustee’s individual beneficial owners indirectly own or control at least 25 percent of the ownership interests of the reporting company through their ownership interests in the corporate trustee. The following examples are provided by FinCEN: If an individual owns 60 percent of the corporate trustee of a trust, and that trust holds 50 percent of a reporting company’s ownership interests, then the individual owns or controls 30 percent (60 percent × 50 percent = 30 percent) of the reporting company’s ownership interests and is, therefore, a beneficial owner of the reporting company. If the same trust only holds 30 percent of the reporting company’s ownership interests, the same individual corporate trustee owner only owns or controls 18 percent (60 percent × 30 percent = 18 percent) of the reporting company, and thus is not a beneficial owner of the reporting company by virtue of ownership or control of ownership interests. The reporting company may, but is not required to, report the name of the corporate trustee in lieu of information about an individual beneficial owner only if all of the following three conditions are met: The corporate trustee is an entity that is exempt from the reporting requirements; The individual beneficial owner owns or controls at least 25 percent of ownership interests in the reporting company only by virtue of ownership interests in the corporate trustee; and The individual beneficial owner does not exercise substantial control over the reporting company. It may also be necessary to consider whether any owners of, or individuals employed or engaged by, the corporate trustee exercise substantial control over a reporting company. The factors for determining substantial control by an individual connected with a corporate trustee are the same as for any beneficial owner. Exemptions from the Definition of Beneficial Owner When any of the following individuals qualifies for an exception, the reporting company does not have to report that individual in its beneficial ownership information report to FinCEN. Minors (Parent or legal guardian of the minor must report instead) Nominees, intermediaries, custodians, or agents Remainder beneficiaries (Once the individual inherits the interest, this exception no longer applies, and the individual may qualify as a beneficial owner) Creditors Penalties for Noncompliance While attorneys and beneficial owners are not directly responsible for filing reports with FinCEN—the onus falls on the reporting company itself—attorneys should be prepared to advise their clients whether a trust falls within the purview of the CTA and which parties associated with a trust must provide beneficial ownership information. Penalties for failing to comply with the CTA may be steep. Parties to a trust who are considered beneficial owners must provide the reporting company with complete and accurate beneficial ownership information. If an individual willfully fails to do so, an enforcement action may be brought against such party because someone who willfully causes a reporting company’s failure to submit complete or updated beneficial ownership information to FinCEN is in violation of the CTA. Violations can result in fines of $500 per day, up to $10,000 (both adjusted for inflation), and imprisonment for up to two years. Civil and criminal liability may be avoided if an individual who submitted an original, erroneous report did not knowingly submit inaccurate information and submits an updated report correcting the inaccurate information within ninety days. Conclusion The beneficial owner information reporting analysis is complex and must be done on a case-by-case basis. A practitioner must review the extensive CTA information published on FinCEN’s website. There is no doubt that clients with trusts and trust-owned businesses will have questions about CTA compliance. Reprinted with permission from the Summer 2024 edition of The Pennsylvania Bar Association's Real Property, Probate & Trust Law Section newsletter. All rights reserved. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. [1] Reporting companies—defined as any company with twenty or fewer employees formed by filing with the Secretary of State or equivalent official—created or registered prior to January 1, 2024, have until January 1, 2025 to file an initial report; reporting companies created or registered after January 1, 2024 and before January 1, 2025, will have ninety days after creation or registration to file a report. Entities created on or after January 1, 2025 will have 30 days to submit the reports to FinCEN. The CTA exempts around two dozen categories of entities, including companies that are publicly-traded; have more than twenty full-time US employees; filed a previous year’s tax return showing more than $5 million in gross receipts or sales; have an operating presence at a physical US office location; operate in a regulated industry, such as banking, utilities, or insurance, that already imposes similar reporting requirements; or are subsidiaries of exempt organizations. The exemptions, which generally include larger companies already subject to regulation, underline the primary purpose of the CTA: to combat money laundering and other illicit activities conducted via small, private, and anonymous shell companies. [2] There are other nuances to this rule if no single owner owns more than 25%. [3] An individual or trust exercises substantial control over a reporting company if the individual or trust meets any of four general criteria: (1) the individual is a senior officer; (2) the individual or trust has authority to appoint or remove certain officers or a majority of directors of the reporting company; (3) the individual or trust is an important decision-maker; or (4) the individual or trust has any other form of substantial control over the reporting company.
August 12, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Estate Planning for Young Professional Athletes: A Comprehensive Guide
The Barclay’s Center in Brooklyn recently buzzed with the first round of the NBA draft — a gathering of young, exceptionally talented players hoping to be drafted to a professional team, the pinnacle and the reward for years of hard work and dedication. As young athletes, their focus rightly revolves around training, competition, and achieving a peak performance. However, it's also important for them to consider their financial future, particularly given the short average duration of an athletic career —only 3.5 to 5.6 years, according to The Bleacher Report. As a result, it is imperative that young athletes start off on the right foot immediately to protect their hard-earned assets, their potentially brief career, and their loved ones. While so many assume that the topic of estate planning is for an older demographic, beginning early can provide peace of mind and secure the athlete’s hard-earned wealth for the future. Why Should Young Athletes Consider an Estate Plan? Financial Security: While athletes can earn significant income early in their careers, the average professional athlete only earns between $362,000 - $680,000 per season, according to the Motley Fool. Proper estate planning is key to ensuring that the young athlete’s assets, whether substantial or not, are managed and protected, providing a stable and secure financial future beyond their career. Uncertainty of Career Length: The length of a professional athlete’s career is highly unpredictable. Injuries, even minor ones, can abruptly end a career or lead to being sidelined, benched, traded, or marginalized. Additionally, the physical demands of professional athlete’s training schedules and physical demands can diminish athletic abilities over time. An estate plan serves as a safety net in case of unexpected events. Family Protection: Many athletes come from families that have collectively pooled their resources to provide the support that propelled the young athlete to the professional arena. When athletes succeed, they often want to protect those who have supported them. The athlete is often relied upon to ensure financial security for themselves and their larger family of origin. An estate plan ensures that the athlete and their family are protected, especially if their career ends earlier than expected. The “Plays” of an Athlete’s Estate Plan Last Will and Testament: A Will is a legal document that outlines how assets will be distributed after death. It names beneficiaries, designates guardians for minor children, and appoints an executor to carry out the athlete’s wishes. Trusts: Often referred to as a Will “substitute,” Trusts offer more privacy, control, and flexibility over the athlete’s asset distribution than a Will. Trusts also help minimize estate taxes, protect assets from creditors and other predatory actors, and provide for loved ones in a structured manner. Power of Attorney: This document grants the athlete’s trusted advisor the authority to make financial decisions on the athlete’s behalf, especially during busy times like pre-season training. If the athlete becomes incapacitated, even temporarily, the Power of Attorney allows another trusted person to make financial decisions on their behalf. It's crucial for the athlete to choose someone who understands their unique financial situation and has their best interests at heart. Healthcare Proxy: Similar to a Power of Attorney, a Healthcare Proxy appoints a person to make medical decisions on behalf of the athlete if the athlete is unable to do so themselves. This ensures that the athlete’s healthcare wishes are respected when they are unable to make decisions themselves. Beneficiary Designations: Often overlooked, beneficiary designations on accounts direct who inherits the asset upon the athlete’s death. It is imperative that the athlete review and update beneficiary designations on life insurance policies, retirement accounts from their respective league, and other financial instruments regularly to ensure they align with the athlete’s Will, Trust, and overall estate plan. The Young Athlete’s Next Move: Assess Your Assets: The young athlete should start simple: list all their assets, including property, investments, intellectual property, and personal items. Set Goals: Determine the goals for the estate plan. What is most important? There is no one right answer: every athlete has different priorities, whether it be financial security for the family, a charitable cause, or minimizing taxes. Regardless of the goal, it can be achieved with the right plan. Consult Professionals: Avoid cautionary tales of athletes who engaged unqualified “professionals” (here’s looking at you, Tim Duncan.) Working with an experienced estate planning attorney, a competent financial advisor, and a skilled accountant will ensure a comprehensive estate plan structured and tailored to the young athlete’s needs. Regular Reviews: The life circumstances of young athletes change frequently. Being traded to a team in a new state with different estate planning rules, experiencing drastic income fluctuations, and evolving interpersonal relationships mean the estate plan must pivot to remain relevant. Regular reviews ensure the plan continues to reflect current circumstances. Estate planning can seem daunting, especially for young athletes just starting their careers. However, taking the time to plan now can provide significant benefits in the future. By securing their financial future, protecting their assets, and ensuring their loved ones are cared for, young athletes can focus on what they do best on the field, the court, or the ice.
July 12, 2024
Commercial Litigation
A Divorce Checklist – Death and Bankruptcy Considerations
A substantial portion of estate and trust litigation and post-divorce enforcement litigation (“contempt proceedings”) is rooted in failures or shortcomings in negotiations or drafting during the divorce process itself. Here is a recommended “best practices” checklist of questions developed based on my nearly three decades of bankruptcy, creditors’ rights, collection and enforcement, and estate and trust litigation. This “best practices” checklist for family law (aka matrimonial law) attorneys, divorce lawyers, those contemplating divorce, and those, perhaps, already in the throes of post-divorce contempt proceedings tracks with my recently published List of “Top 5 Divorce-related Financial Protection Failures”. It incorporates lessons learned “the hard way” from potentially avoidable situations occasioned or worsened when the questions compiled here had not been considered or, if asked, ineffectively taken into account by the drafting attorneys involved in the first instance. This checklist is a practical, check-the-box application of the “Top 5 List” broken down into specific questions to be asked and answered by all involved in the divorce process. The checklist can and should be relied upon and applied (in whole or in part, depending on the circumstances) during multiple phases of a divorce proceeding. The checklist should help guide drafting considerations during negotiations of a Property Settlement Agreement when trying to avoid or limit costly equitable distribution litigation to determine how much each spouse is equitably to receive; otherwise to be measured by what portion of which assets the judge determines most appropriate after costly hearings. The checklist similarly serves to guide drafting considerations of the final divorce decree itself. Furthermore, although the checklist is intended to reduce costs and delays associated with post-divorce litigation used to hold a non-compliant spouse accountable when not adhering to one or more financial terms of the divorce, it can be equally effective during these contempt proceedings at aiding decision-making and providing both cost-saving guidance and time-saving benefits for the user. If routinely followed and effectively applied, the checklist should serve to help avoid unintended negative financial consequences while reducing future litigation and related legal fees, costs, and delays. THE CHECKLIST Insurance Notice to Provider - Has the insurance company (and/or benefits provider) been notified and / or asked about relevant policies and procedures for irrevocably assigning policy proceeds (and precluding unilateral re-designation of beneficiaries by the insured)? Beneficiary Re-designation - Have policy beneficiaries been irrevocably re-designated to identify ex-spouse (and/or child, children, or trust) expressly by name? Account Access – Has perpetual real-time account access to policy information (including, most importantly, payment status and continuing coverage) been irrevocably established? Employment Coverage - If relying upon employer-provided insurance coverage, have conditions or contingencies been established for the continuance of coverage upon termination, or if work-related coverage benefits ceases to be provided for any reason? Premium Payments - What specific protections (e.g., Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust (ILIT) or escrow) have been established to assure continuity of premium payments if the debtor-spouse refuses or is unable to pay for any reason? Real Estate Clean Title - Have you verified that there are no mechanics liens, judgment liens, or other title impediments? Premature Death - Have you analyzed and provided sufficiently for the possibility and potential impact of the premature death of either spouse? HELOC - Have you protected against additional credit extensions in addition to making appropriate arrangements for payoff or paydown? “Robbing Peter” - If an asset is to be liquidated and paid over in whole or in part, have you established consequences, contingencies, and otherwise protected against proceeds of the asset(s) being improperly disposed of, including in satisfaction of a separate financial obligation? Retitling/Disposition – Have you documented that “time is of the essence” and maximized protection of “reciprocal rights” against bankruptcy and/or failed pre-condition(s) to relinquishing, re-titling, or otherwise disposing of assets, especially real property assets? Retirement Accounts/Benefits Notice to Providers - Have all benefits managers/providers of relevant retirement accounts and benefits been given sufficient notice of all changes? Beneficiary Re-Designations - As with insurance coverages, have all beneficiaries been appropriately and irrevocably re-designated? Claim Deadlines – If in a jurisdiction with time limits on claims against a decedent’s estate (e.g., MD – 6 months), have adequate disclosures been made to assure timely action after death? Spousal Payout Elections – If applicable, have appropriate elections been irrevocably made to assure manner and means of payout after death (e.g., continuing spousal payments v. payments terminating at death)? Borrowing Restrictions – Have any outstanding loans against any retirement assets been factored in for valuation purposes and future borrowing against such assets been appropriately and irrevocably restricted? Bankruptcy Jurisdiction - Do you know what, if any, continuing jurisdiction the “divorce court” has if a bankruptcy is filed? Different Chapters - What difference, if any, would the filing of a Chapter 7, 11, 13, or “Subchapter V” bankruptcy have on your situation? “DSO’s” - Have you negotiated financial obligations regarding future PSA payments concerning whether they are subject to characterization under bankruptcy law as “domestic support obligations?” “The Automatic Stay” - Are you prepared to seek relief from the automatic stay and or pursue enforcement in bankruptcy court if a filing is forthcoming? Corporate Assets - If division and/or control of corporate assets by or between one or both of the spouses is/are to be factored, has a potential bankruptcy filing been accounted for with relevant valuation and enforcement considerations? Collectability Limitations Contempt Jurisdiction - Have you sufficiently familiarized yourself with binding local precedent regarding the scope of continuing contempt jurisdiction of the “divorce court” in the event of a bankruptcy filing? Bankruptcy Clawback/Discharge - Have you evaluated whether, and/or the likelihood of, future financial obligations might be subject to clawback or discharge in bankruptcy (and/or how the outcome/impact might differ depending on which bankruptcy chapter or sub-chapter is pursued)? Third-Party Requirements - For known assets held or controlled by third parties, has/have any specifically needed language been incorporated into the PSA, divorce decree, or contempt order to avoid later having to seek additional judicial relief as a pre-condition to third-party cooperation? Escrows/POA’s - Presuming future ex-spouse noncompliance, what, if any, limited power of attorney language and/or separate writings might be included, created, and/or escrowed to avoid, potentially altogether, future ex-spouse involvement? “Double-Duty” PSA - As a potential failsafe, have you incorporated language of present intent and otherwise satisfied necessary elements for the PSA itself to serve if/as needed as a deed, written assignment, or other ownership conveyance? (See [TWR’s “PSA as Deed”] and [TWR’s “PSA as Equitable Assignment”]
July 11, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Top 5 Divorce-Related Financial Protection Failures
Inadequate Insurance Assurances Uncorrectable Real Estate Refinancing/Retitling Shortcomings Unclaimed Retirement Benefits Unconsidered Bankruptcy Impacts Unconsidered Collectability Limitations Death and Insolvency Considerations as Divorce-related “Best Practices” Divorce lawyers routinely fail to protect clients against an ex-spouse’s failure and/or outright refusal to comply with the terms of the documents governing the termination of the marriage relationship between their client and their client’s soon-to-be ex-spouse. As an estates and trusts litigator, with nearly thirty (30) years of relevant creditors’ rights and bankruptcy experience, I have seen innumerable cases involving avoidable–if not always easily foreseeable!–situations occasioned at least partly by shortcomings in the language of the documents generated and relied upon in a client’s divorce proceedings. In short, many, if not most, of the more costly post-divorce, death-related and non-compliance enforcement/collection matters can be substantially mitigated, if not completely avoided, by additional considerations at the drafting stage. With a backward-looking inquiry addressing “how could this ‘new’ costly litigation have been avoided?” assuring that these death and collection-related matters make the “best practices” checklist in any divorce-related legal planning only makes sense. Top Five Divorce-related Financial Protection Failures The top five divorce-related financial protection failures are as follows: Inadequate Insurance Assurances – Failure to assure irrevocable designation of proper policy beneficiaries and unlimited access to policy-related information are primary among divorce “to do” list items not done. Similarly, divorce lawyers do their clients a disservice by failing to take sufficient steps to assure that insurance coverage remains in place, typically by neglecting to include a plan or structure assuring the payment of, and means to make, policy premium payments. A written assignment of policy proceeds is a necessary consideration, as is job-loss protection against either potentially willful or involuntary loss of employment where the insurance coverage relied upon is a benefit provided by a spouse’s employer and, therefore, only an option so long as the employment continues. Providing for a client anticipating death benefits to have perpetual, real-time access to policy information is an easy way to afford a client the means to protect themselves against the future indifference and/or neglect of a willfully non-compliant ex-spouse who fails to keep up premium payments. In circumstances justifying the added expense, the imposition of and well-considered funding of an irrevocable life insurance trust, or “ILIT,” may provide the highest level of protection short of pre-paying policy premiums for the entire life of the policy (which is itself, a non-option in more than 99% of cases). Uncorrectable Real Estate Refinancing/Retitling Shortcomings – Failure to provide properly or sufficiently for failed refinancing/retitling of marital assets converts a hypothetical remedial benefit into a potentially cost-prohibitive non-option. Many divorces include commitments to sever ties between spouses both as to title and financing commitments related to the marital residence or other jointly held real property. It is not enough to provide for a simple “what if” scenario involving the failure to refinance, retitle, or otherwise dispose of a real property asset by one spouse for the benefit of the other, or, for that matter, to include some form of reciprocal rights of the other spouse in the event the first fails to achieve the contemplated refinancing, retitling, etc. Best practices in this regard ought to consider unanticipated, untimely death-related scenarios. For instance, what if the hypothetical “what if” scenario arises because of suicide? What if the titular owner of the real property dies unexpectedly before carrying out the contemplated transfer of title? Thorough planning in this regard would necessarily consider the existence and potential interaction of an existing will or trust, or of the intestacy hypothetically arising due to the lack thereof. Unclaimed Retirement Benefits – Much like the unfortunate situations involving life insurance policies with unchanged beneficiary designations, failure to provide for proper notice and/or re-designation of retirement plan beneficiaries can mean the difference between a divorce client’s future perpetual financial security and potential ruin. First and foremost, it is not enough to include a provision in a divorce-related agreement that one simply agrees that a particular someone shall receive the proceeds of one’s work-related pension, 401k, or other ERISA-qualified retirement account. In fact, it is not enough to include such a commitment generally in one’s will, trust, or other testamentary document. One must communicate one’s change in beneficiary designations directly to and with the account broker/provider (or, in many cases, through official means managed by one’s employer acting as the provider’s agent). Such a change is most typically accomplished by submitting a signed beneficiary designation change form or via an electronic equivalent. Again, it is not enough to request such a form, or even to complete such a form without “delivery” of such a form to the provider or its agent. Here, best practices should include confirmation requirements and not merely a commitment to timely effect the change. Query whether pre-compliance, untimely death considerations ought not also be taken into consideration in this instance as a best practice, as well. The better question is why one wouldn’t at least include this on the checklist of considerations when deciding whether to expend any additional resources in protecting against such a risk. Unconsidered Bankruptcy Impacts – Failure to contemplate “what if” scenarios of possible bankruptcy filings by either or both divorcing parties or a related business entity (e.g. individually to try to delay or avoid support obligations or of a business the value, cashflow, and/or operational continuity of which as a critical marital asset served to leverage negotiated concessions). There is no “one size fits all” bankruptcy provision to plug into divorce-related property settlement agreements, just as every divorce gives rise to a necessarily factually unique set of circumstances. What is most important is that when negotiating asset transfers and contemplating spouse #1 v. #2, one factors the potential impact of bankruptcy scenarios into asset values and negotiates accordingly. Client risk tolerances and, possibly, actual threats or perceived intentions regarding post-divorce bankruptcy filings comprise the most important considerations. One does not necessarily need to incorporate potential bankruptcy language in every divorce agreement but failing to make or seek a bankruptcy risk/impact evaluation only invites subsequent client dissatisfaction, potential Bar complaints, and perhaps even potential malpractice considerations. Unconsidered Limitations on Collectability – Failure to consider requirements of financial institutions and other third-party asset holders likely comes at a future cost and with potentially significant unwarranted delays. It should be no surprise that divorcees do not always live up to their financial commitments in divorce-related agreements and/or divorce decrees. Contempt proceedings and related remedies are not unto themselves the only mechanism to be employed when it comes to securing payment and satisfaction of divorce-related financial obligations. In fact, contempt proceedings themselves generally give rise to additional financial obligations, the collection of which is not a foregone conclusion and rarely, if ever, immediate. Contempt awards are frequently not satisfied immediately. Consequently, the financial relief a successful contempt proceeding is intended to provide often comes, if at all, only after imposing additional financial burdens on the “creditor spouse.” When a “debtor spouse” refuses to make divorce-obligated payments, a creditor-spouse can employ the contempt process to quantify and formally liquidate the amount(s) owed in an enforceable court order (sometimes coming only after the threat of or actual jail time). Having secured entry of a liquidated contempt order amount, one still needs to enforce the order to satisfy the newly liquidated debt. Such enforcement actions (such as garnishments, attachments, asset seizures, turnover actions, etc.) again mean additional legal fees and costs, but here’s where some pre-planning can potentially reduce or avoid even more fees, costs, and delays. Applying some “creditor’s rights” know-how during the contempt process, including considering known third-party asset holder’s risks and requirements, can be a substantial difference maker. It might very well avoid altogether the need for a secondary enforcement proceeding.
June 20, 2024
Family Law
Should Your Wedding Checklist Include a Prenup?
Fans of The Golden Girls may remember the episode in which Dorothy decides to remarry her ex-husband, Stan. He’s the selfish, cheating, novelty salesman Dorothy had married as a teenager in a shotgun wedding. Although they are now divorced, Stan remains the bane of Dorothy’s existence. She calls him, without irony, a “yellow-bellied sleaze ball,” among other epithets. Dorothy’s decision to remarry Stan has Rose, Blanche, and Sophia all rolling their eyes. It is only on the day of the wedding, when Stan unexpectedly asks Dorothy to sign a prenuptial agreement, that she comes to her senses and calls it off. “I don’t want to make the same mistake twice,” she tells her disbelieving guests. A prenuptial agreement may be the least romantic thing an engaged couple can talk about. Simply bringing up the topic may arouse suspicion, suggesting a lack of good faith or an expectation of divorce. But rather than any want of sincerity, preparing a prenup can reflect a couple’s maturity and respect for each other. The process of sorting through the terms of the agreement may even bring them closer together. Under Maryland law, the separate assets each partner brings to a marriage belong to that person, even if the marriage ends in divorce. The assets they acquire during the marriage, however, would be divided equitably between them in the event of a breakup. A prenup is a contingency plan that enables the couple to say what that division should look like. For example, each partner could simply take what they separately contributed to the union and be on their way. Or the partner with greater assets could agree to support the other long enough for them to get back on their feet. The agreement can also say what happens to the family home. Should one partner be allowed to buy out the other’s interest in the house? Or should the property be sold and the proceeds divided according to the percentages each of them contributed to the down payment and mortgage installments? Children are another consideration. If one partner has children from a prior relationship, the agreement could allow him to bequeath his entire estate to them, rather than his new spouse. This provision would trump the surviving spouse’s legal right to take a third or more of the estate as her “spousal share.” If the couple already has children together, one or both spouses could agree to maintain life insurance for the children’s benefit while they are still minors. The one thing a prenup cannot dictate is custody of the parties’ own children in the event of divorce. Regardless of what provisions it includes, a prenuptial agreement can be a reassuring document to have in the fire safe. It’s a lot like the airbag in your car—you hope you’ll never have to use it, but you’ll be grateful to have it if the need arises. As a practical matter, that need may be more likely to arise for some couples than for others. With the arrival of same-sex marriage, many couples are tying the knot after having been together for years or even decades. These relationships have already withstood the test of time and are unlikely to end in divorce. But two people in a newer relationship may like the idea of a prenup so they can enter into marriage prepared for the unexpected. In the same way, couples who are significantly different in age, wealth, or level of education should give a prenuptial agreement serious consideration. Having children from a prior marriage is another circumstance in which a prenup may be advisable. If Dorothy Zbornak, already in her wedding dress, had gone ahead and signed Stan’s prenup, it probably wouldn’t have held up in court. Stan, ever the yutz, had neglected to follow some important formalities. First, the document should include full financial disclosures from both partners. Any omission could invalidate the agreement. Second, two attorneys should be involved, one to represent the separate interests of each partner. And third, sufficient time should be allowed between executing the agreement and exchanging vows to avoid the suggestion that either partner was pressured into signing. A valid prenuptial agreement can save a couple time, money, and heartache if things don’t go as expected. If there are wedding bells in your future, contact an attorney who practices in this area to determine whether a prenuptial agreement is right for you.
May 15, 2024
Estates and Trusts
When Athletes Stumble: The Perilous Pitfalls of Financial Scams and the Simple Legal Mechanisms to Stop Them
In a world where reputation is paramount, athletes often stand as symbols of hard work, determination, wealth, and success. Despite their celebrity, they are not immune to the snares of financial scams. Take, for example, the LA Dodger’s own Shohei Ohtani’s former interpreter, who pled guilty just last week to bank and tax fraud after admitting to stealing more than $16M from the Dodger’s phenom. It drew to mind the NBA’s own Tim Duncan, who lost more than $20M to an unscrupulous financial advisor, leading Duncan down a seven-year path of bad investment after bad investment. From musicians (here’s looking at you, Billy Joel) to politicians and athletes to actors like Kevin Bacon, a victim of Bernie Madoff, the list of those who have fallen victim to fraudulent schemes is as diverse as it is alarming. In this article, we delve into the web of financial scams and explore why even the most prominent athletes at the top of their game can become ensnared. We will also offer insight into simple ways that others in their position can avoid the quandary in which Shohei, Tim, Billy, and Kevin found themselves. The Allure of the Scheme Scams come in various guises, each designed to exploit vulnerabilities and capitalize on trust. Whether it's a Ponzi scheme promising unrealistic returns, a phishing scam targeting personal information, or old-fashioned fraud, perpetrators often employ sophisticated tactics to ensnare their victims. The allure of these schemes can be particularly potent for athletes and public figures. With wealth and often hectic training and game schedules, many athletes entrust their financial affairs to advisors or hangers-on, unwittingly exposing themselves to exploitation. Moreover, the desire for greater returns or the fear of missing out on lucrative opportunities can cloud judgment, making them susceptible to manipulation. Trust Betrayed One of the most devastating aspects of financial scams is the betrayal of trust. In Shohei’s case, his translator, the person he relied upon to bridge language barriers, engage with the press, and provide the in-game interpretation that Shohei needed to perform, was the culprit, gambling away what many believe is more than $20M in total, $16M of which came from Shohei. For Tim Duncan, his financial advisor, whom he had trusted for nearly a decade, unwittingly involved Duncan in speculative investments and risky loans and took Duncan down with him. Busy athletes rightly place their faith in advisors, managers, and associates to safeguard their assets and guide their financial decisions. When that trust is violated, the repercussions can be profound, both financially and emotionally. The Power of Due Diligence While no one is immune to the threat of financial scams, athletes can take steps to mitigate their risk. Chief among these steps is the power of due diligence and having proper legal mechanisms plan in place to reduce exposure. By thoroughly vetting financial advisors and lawyers, conducting independent research, scrutinizing investment opportunities, and then creating the proper legal infrastructure of checks and balances, athletes can better protect themselves from potential scams. Financial advisors, as licensed professionals, undergo scrutiny to ensure their integrity. Their licenses are subject to review for any prior acts of misconduct. At large institutions, advisors face additional scrutiny from their compliance departments. Ensuring that client assets are invested properly, aligning with the standards of a prudent investor based on the asset amount, age, and relationship to risk. Licensing and infrastructure can go a long way to ensure that one bad actor cannot misuse funds. Like financial advisors, lawyers also hold licenses and have their own areas of concentration. If an athlete requires legal assistance for estate and financial documents, most likely, they should consult a lawyer other than the one that drew up his playing contract. Instead, the athlete should turn to a lawyer who has expertise in properly drafting estate planning and financial documents that will insulate and thwart predators from penetrating the athlete’s financial assets. Trust the Process The level of protection that a properly drafted legal infrastructure to manage an athlete’s assets cannot be understated. Most estate plans for athletes and other public figures include one or more Trust instruments to accomplish this protection. Trust instruments, whether revocable or irrevocable, can own all types of assets; from the earnings of a lucrative contract to real estate to business ventures to life insurance, a Trust is the vehicle that manages most assets for athletes. First and foremost, when a Trust is created, it is private. There is no disclosure to the public or in the public record to disclose the identity of the Trust creator. A Last Will and Testament, for example, is a public record that can be viewed and reviewed by any member of the public. Trust assets are held and distributed without notice to anyone other than those authorized in the Trust instrument. Upon the athlete’s death, their estate is likewise distributed without an action of the court or notice to the public. The bequests that the athlete makes in his Trust can also be made in further Trust to protect the athlete’s family members from the same financial vulnerability they may have faced during their lives. It Takes Two When a Trust is created, the role of the Trustee is vitally important to protect the athlete from wrongdoing. As the name implies, the Trustee must be trusted. The Trustee’s job is to manage Trust assets, make investments, and distribute income and principal among countless other financial transactions related to Trust assets. Many of my public figure clients are inclined to appoint their closest friend or a family member in this role for their rightful fear of exploitation. While often these relationships are the most trusted, these individuals may lack the necessary skill set to effectively manage such significant assets and stave off financial scams and opportunistic predators. For those with significant assets like athletes and other public figures, having more than one Trustee appointed in this capacity may make sense, requiring that they act jointly. For practical purposes, appointing two Trustees requires two signatures, two sets of eyes, and two individuals reviewing transactions. Simply put, an act of fraud is much harder to commit when two Trustees are involved. When two individuals are appointed, the most trusted person together, with someone with the financial acuity, can work as a team to ensure that the athlete does not fall victim like so many who came before them. Leave it to the Professional Choosing the right Trustee to execute the athlete’s wishes and oversee their Trust assets typically requires a professional with the expertise to navigate the complexity of significant net worth. Given the complexities involved, including tax considerations, intricate investment vehicles, and corporate structures, an independent corporate Trustee is often necessary. A corporate Trustee is not an individual but rather a financial institution, such as a bank or investment firm, that assumes the fiduciary responsibility of managing a Trust. Athletes often hire corporate Trustees for their professional experience, financial acumen, and legal knowledge in trust matters, qualities that a trusted family member or friend may not possess. Hiring a corporate Trustee to collaborate with the athlete’s trusted family member or friend provides an additional layer of protection against financial misconduct. This partnership ensures that the athlete’s assets are safeguarded and minimizes the risk of unchecked financial mismanagement that could occur with the sole reliance on one individual. The Road to Recovery For those who have fallen victim to financial scams, the road to recovery can be long and arduous. Beyond the immediate financial losses, there may be legal battles, reputational damage, and emotional trauma to contend with. The prevalence of financial scams is a stark reminder that no one is immune to deception, regardless of their stats on the court or stature in pop culture. Shining a spotlight on financial scams and sharing personal experiences like those of Tim and Shohei can help raise awareness, potentially preventing others from suffering a similar fate. Thoroughly vetting professionals and ensuring that athletes or public figures have the proper legal documents in place can help to avoid a similar fate.
May 15, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Four Reasons Your Power of Attorney May be Out of Date
A financial Power of Attorney is an essential document in any estate plan. It enables you to appoint someone you trust to manage your finances and other legal matters in case you become unable to do so yourself. The person you name, called your “attorney in fact,” generally has broad powers to handle things like paying your bills, filing your taxes, accessing your safe deposit box, managing your investments, and even selling or mortgaging your house. A “Durable” Power of Attorney remains in effect even if you become incompetent, which is when the document is most likely to be needed. Because it may be years before your Power of Attorney is used, you should review it periodically to make sure it remains current. Here are four reasons to consider having your Power of Attorney revised: It is more than five years old. Unless the document states otherwise, a Power of Attorney technically remains valid indefinitely. Still, banks and other financial institutions may be skeptical if the document is more than five years old. Their skepticism may stem from a legitimate concern that the Power of Attorney has been revoked or perhaps superseded by a newer version of the document. It names the wrong people. Longtime partners and married couples often name each other as their attorneys, in fact, and another individual to act as a backup in case the partner or spouse isn’t able to do the job. If your marital status has changed since you had your Power of Attorney prepared, or if your backup attorney, in fact, has fallen out of favor, it’s time to rethink who should be in charge of your finances if you can’t be. It’s Not the Maryland Statutory Form. In October 2023, the Maryland Legislature adopted a new Statutory Power of Attorney. Under state law, Maryland’s banks, insurance companies, and brokerage firms are legally obligated to accept this statutory form. Anyone who refuses to honor the Statutory Power of Attorney can be forced to pay the attorney’s fees spent getting a court to require that they accept the document. Although other Power of Attorney forms are still valid in Maryland, having the statutory form will help to ensure that the document is honored without delay. It doesn’t include provisions for your digital assets. Digital assets include things like the electronic data stored on your computer or smartphone, your Internet accounts like LinkedIn and Gmail, and your online pictures and documents. Without explicit authorization, called “lawful consent,” no one can legally manage these assets for you if you become incapacitated. Some of these assets, like your PayPal or Amazon accounts, may have monetary value. Others, like your email account or personal blog page, could be of great sentimental importance. Even your voicemail account may be valuable if it includes messages from potential clients or expressions of support from loved ones during an illness. Only a newer Power of Attorney will include provisions for your digital assets, and it may be wise to have yours updated for this reason alone. It is also important to make a list of your passwords and login information. This should be kept in a safe place so your attorney, in fact, can find it when the need arises. Do you really need a Power of Attorney? Without one, it could be necessary for the court to appoint someone to become your legal guardian. A guardianship proceeding is an arduous and expensive process. In addition, the guardian would need to file annual accountings with the court to verify how your assets had been spent. Taking the time to have a Power of Attorney prepared—and to keep it current—is well worth the small effort required. Lee Carpenter is a Principal at the law firm of Offit Kurman, P.A., and can be reached at (410) 209-6426 or lee.carpenter@offitkurman.com. This article is intended to provide general information and should not be construed as legal advice.
March 4, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Five Biggest Mistakes of Estate Planning
#5 - Inequity The fifth biggest mistake of estate planning is presuming to treat everyone equally, equaled only by the error of presuming to treat your loved ones differently because you don’t think they need anything or, in the other extreme, that they don’t deserve anything. Perhaps you’ve given more to one in life and intend to balance things in death. Unless you intend to include a detailed accounting (and even then?), I urge you to reconsider in this regard. Similarly, choosing who is to serve in what role (attorney-in-fact under a power of attorney, executor, or trustee, for instance) based on perceived fairness or not wanting to seem inequitable is a mistake. Have a reason, trust your judgment, and choose someone based on your sound judgment (for instance, she’s the oldest; he’s a lawyer; she’s the only one who hasn’t done time… these are all good reasons). Worse, appointing two co-fiduciaries (i.e., co-attorneys-in-fact, co-executors, or co-trustees, might be the biggest mistake of all - especially if you refuse to provide the two co-equals with a means of breaking a deadlock. If there are two empowered to make decisions and they don’t agree on something, if you’ve not authorized a coin flip or other means to break the tie (rock, paper, scissors, perhaps?!), their only recourse is to the courts. Don’t do it…don’t name two co-equal decision-makers to manage your affairs when you die. If you simply can’t help yourself, at least give them a fighting chance and tell them what to do when they disagree (if considering a coin flip, I suggest making it at least two out of three!). #4 – Sentimentality The fourth biggest mistake of estate planning is presuming one or more of your loved ones “wouldn’t want” something of yours, or alternatively, planning based on presumed values ascribed to the “objects of your bounty.” It is difficult to nearly impossible to know accurately what one of your kids might value over another, and you should take no offense by loved ones’ avoiding the subject altogether or making statements to the effect that they don’t want anything of yours. Everyone deals with death and the loss or thoughts of loss of a loved one in one’s own way. That said, it may, of course, be true that they don’t want your stuff; your style and tastes may be embarrassingly outdated. It may also be true that they don’t need anything, have the space for things they might want, or might not want to be perceived as thoughtless or greedy by asking for something of yours, for instance, before you are even in the ground! Rather than take offense or think, “How dare they!” consider over-sharing and discussing more with them, not less. Force them to face truths none of us generally care to acknowledge — first and foremost of which, you are going to die! Hate to be the one to burst that bubble for you, but it happens to all of us eventually. Too often, I see families left squabbling over misperceived intentions and failing/refusing to face these avoidable issues head-on, which brings us to the third biggest estate planning mistake. #3 – Communication The third biggest mistake of estate planning is failing to involve your beneficiaries in the planning. You need not give them a say in your plans necessarily or even seek their input per se, at least not everyone’s!, but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t involve them at all, even if only to communicate that you’ve made a plan and where/how it can be found. Those who intend to play a role later should be consulted. The executor (or “personal representative”), who will oversee the administration of your probate estate; the trustee, who you will count on to manage assets you’ve opted to have held/protected from creditors and managed for the benefit of those you may not completely trust to manage them effectively for themselves (either because of their immaturity, addictions, or other special needs); and especially guardians of any minor children you might leave behind…these should all be consulted and confirmed before being named and saddled with such responsibilities. After all, they may not want or be able to handle the responsibility and/or their own life circumstances may not be fully known to you and may not make them the best choice. To minimize the risk of mistaken choices in this regard, don’t compound the mistake by failing to name a backup and a backup to the backup and also setting forth a means of picking the person you would want to be next in line should all else fail. #2 – Indecision The second biggest mistake of estate planning is changing your plans. This one comprises a whole series of mistakes. Changing one’s mind is ok, of course. The timing of a revised estate plan is one of the primary factors when litigation is later considered. Doing so after declining mental health, shortly before or after major life events, just prior to death (on one’s deathbed!), and/or with the involvement or input of less than all of one’s beneficiaries virtually assures legal wrangling after you’re gone, or, at the very least, likely breeds ill will among your loved ones in ways you can’t possibly fully anticipate. Compounding this mistake with less than full and open communication about your planning efforts (refer back to #3!) frequently sparks resentment and even hostility when you yourself have set different and differing expectations among those to whom you intend to benefit. If you opt to share your planning documents, do so with all of your beneficiaries. If you opt to make a change, be sure to communicate any changes to everyone, preferably with very specifically communicated reasons why. Oftentimes, in addition to breeding resentment for each other, change, especially uncommunicated changes to one’s estate plan, leaves your loved ones resenting you, even when they are the ones benefiting from the change! #1 – Inertia The number one biggest mistake of estate planning is not to plan. A favorite lyric from a group I’ve enjoyed since the 80s goes as follows: “If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice.” Not planning, i.e., not creating a will or other document directing the disposition of assets upon your death, is the equivalent of deciding you want your loved ones to experience the costly, time-consuming, living hell that can often be the result of doing nothing. Don’t let inertia be your guide. Have a plan… execute the plan. Do it now; tomorrow may never come. Carpe diem!
January 29, 2024
Estates and Trusts
2024 Update – Federal Exemption and Exclusion Amounts
Beginning January 1, 2024, the IRS has increased the federal estate tax exemption to $13.61 million per person and $27.22 million for married couples. This increase also applies to the lifetime gifting exemption and means that individuals can transfer up to $13.61 million tax-free during their lifetime or at death. Married couples can double the exemption amount through portability and gift-splitting. As a result of the increased exemption amount, individuals who have previously used all of their lifetime gifting exemption now have an additional $690,000 that they may use to make gifts in 2024. Additionally, the 2024 annual gift tax exclusion amount has increased from $17,000 to $18,000 per donee in 2024. The increased exclusion also means that a married couple may gift up to $36,000 in gifts to individuals this year. Although the exemption amounts have increased for 2024, it is important to note that the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, the federal legislation that increased these estate and gifting exemptions, is set to end on December 31, 2025. Unless Congress acts in the interim, the federal exemption amounts will revert to $5 million per individual (adjusted for inflation) on January 1, 2026. As a result, it is best to consider gifting now while the exemption amounts are higher and perhaps earlier in the year before the 2024 election in the event of further congressional action. An experienced planning attorney can advise you on estate and gift tax avoidance strategies that may be of benefit to you and/or your family.
January 4, 2024
Estates and Trusts
Wealth with Wisdom: Leaving Educational Legacies in Your Estate Plan
As estate planning attorneys, we guide our clients in distributing their wealth to the next generation efficiently. However, Guy Fieri and Shaquille O’Neal recently made headlines by stating that their children need to earn two degrees to inherit from them. There is a trend articulated in the headlines, namely that tying inheritances to education goals, especially the size of inheritances from celebrities like Shaq, should contribute to the personal and intellectual growth of your children. Conditions requiring certain educational milestones or that an inheritance may only be used toward this goal in order to inherit from a loved one can be a powerful way to leave a lasting impact. The following are a few tips to consider when exploring the idea of leaving assets in your estate plan with educational conditions for your children, emphasizing the importance of combining financial legacy with a commitment to lifelong learning. The Purpose of Leaving Educational Legacies: Empowering Future Generations: When a condition of education is articulated in an estate plan, a message is received. That message, stating that education is a prerequisite to receiving an inheritance, not only encourages your child to pursue additional education but also sends a message that you believe life is more than just financial security, that education is a prerequisite to obtaining that financial security. It is the hope of many of my clients who choose to have educational prerequisites in their estate plan that they not only instill the importance of learning but perhaps demonstrate that education can empower them to also accumulate wealth for future generations. Fostering a Growth Mindset: A requirement that a child meets an educational condition can also encourage a “growth mindset.” Many clients see this condition as a conduit to inspire their children to embrace the challenge of higher learning. So many of our clients who worked hard to accumulate their own wealth have concerns that simply handing over an inheritance will mean that their own child will never face the challenges that the client has faced nor understand the value of “hard work” or the “struggle” to succeed and accumulate wealth. Placing a “two degrees” condition on an inheritance might be a way for your child to not only prove to themselves that they are up to the challenge, but the hope is that further education will also better equip the child to not only manage the inheritance more efficiently but also have a greater appreciation for that inheritance. How to Create Educational Conditions: How the Funds Can be Spent? Your Will or Trust is your “universe,” and therefore, it can define the educational conditions and expenditures as you see fit. For example, an inheritance can be left in trust, and distributions might only be made for tuition and educational expenses related to pursuing a college or an advanced degree. You may even specify what portion of the inheritance can be allocated to cover the costs associated with pursuing a degree and further define those expenses (i.e., books and transportation but not living expenses). The requirements can be even more granular to state that an inheritance can only be used to pay for graduate school in a particular field of study that a parent deems worthwhile. Educational Attainment Milestones: Like Shaq and Guy, many clients determine that their child’s entire inheritance is conditional upon earning a degree. As Shaq said so eloquently, “No cheese without two degrees.” Guy has made public statements following Shaq’s lead. Unless the O’Neal and Fieri children earn two college degrees each, they will not inherit at all from their fathers. Milestones like these are easy to add to an estate plan and are easily enforceable. As already mentioned, the spirit behind the milestones is to foster that growth mindset and empower their family’s future generation to ensure a more educated family tree. The hope is that the more educated the child, the more responsible they will be in managing those assets and preserving the wealth for generations to come. Important Details to Consider: Flexibility: Life is unpredictable, so it’s important that your estate planning documents are drafted in such a way that it is possible to adapt to life’s changing circumstances, particularly for your children. It is essential to design your educational conditions with flexibility to accommodate unforeseen challenges or opportunities for your children. Perhaps this means that you should extend the scope beyond traditional education to include opportunities for professional development, ensuring your children are equipped for success in their chosen fields. What happens if your child, while responsible and hardworking, is not college-bound? Conditions can also be tied to earning a vocational degree or being gainfully employed. Additionally, conditions can be tailored to encourage entrepreneurial ventures to foster their creativity or business acumen. Communication: Communication is key! If you want to empower your children and foster a growth mindset, you need to share this with your children. Therefore, it is so important when these types of estate planning conditions are imposed that they are communicated transparently to your children so that they have the opportunity to meet and exceed the conditions. It would be best to discuss your intentions with your children so they fully understand the conditions, how the funds can and cannot be used, and your rationale for imposing these conditions. Trusteeship. It cannot be understated how important it is to appoint a Trustee who will not only enforce the terms of your educational conditions but also understand and respect them. A trustee will enforce the terms of the conditions to ensure that all of the terms are met by your children. Most importantly, the trustee will be your voice long after you’re gone and can help communicate those educational conditions to your children so that they can successfully manage their inheritance and their future security. In conclusion, leaving assets in your estate plan with educational conditions for your children is a profound way to extend your influence beyond your lifetime. By intertwining financial legacies with a commitment to education, you not only provide for their immediate needs but also empower them with the tools to thrive intellectually and professionally. As you plan for the future, consider the legacy of wisdom and knowledge you can pass on to future generations, leaving a lasting impact on their lives.
December 22, 2023
Estates and Trusts
When to Review your Estate Plan: The 5 Ds
Originally posted 12/17/2020, no content changes. You finally sat down with an estate planning attorney after years of procrastination and created an estate plan that reflects your wishes: can you file it away with the rest of your important documents and never think about it again? Not exactly. As a rule of thumb, you should review your estate plan every three years or when there are significant tax changes at the state or federal level - much like the changes (likely) on the horizon this January. However, if your life has been touched by the 5 D's - Death, Disability, Divorce, Distance, and/or Descendants you should speak with your estate planner right away. Death When a family member or close friend dies, there are a few reasons to trigger a review of your own estate plan. First, the deceased loved one may have left you a significant inheritance that changes the schematic of your own estate plan from a tax perspective. Receiving a large inheritance will necessitate a review of your plan to ensure that you have considered the tax ramifications of the same. Second, the deceased loved one may have been named as a fiduciary in your estate plan. If you named the deceased loved one as your agent under a Power of Attorney, or Health Care Proxy, it is important to review those documents to make sure that you have an alternate agent and if you do not, you should update those documents right away. In your own Will, if the deceased loved one is a beneficiary of your estate, are you satisfied with who will inherit from you instead of the deceased loved one? It is often necessary to revise the plan of distribution considering a loved one's death. Disability Receiving a diagnosis of an illness or life altering condition for you or a loved one can be overwhelming. In addition to grappling with the realities of a diagnosis, it is imperative to review your estate plan from the lens of that disability. For example, if your spouse is diagnosed with a memory impairment condition such as dementia or Parkinson’s Disease, your estate plan should be reviewed by an elder law attorney to make sure that your assets are held in a trust that will allow for Medicaid eligibility in the future to pay for care one day. If a beneficiary in your Will is now disabled and relies on public benefits to pay for his care, you may wish to revise your own Will to direct that your disabled loved one's bequest is left in trust for him, so that his future inheritance will not disqualify him from the benefits upon which he relies for his disability. If you received a diagnosis, you should make sure that those you nominated as your agents under your Power of Attorney and Health Care directives are the people you still entrust with these particularly important and vital roles. Divorce If your marital status changes - a divorce, or a new marriage, your estate plan will certainly change. In the case of a divorce, each of your estate planning documents should be reviewed. If your estate plan was created during your marriage, it is likely that you chose your former spouse to act as your agent under a Power of Attorney and Health Care Proxy and as Executor or Trustee under your Will or Trust. In many states, a divorce will automatically end such an appointment without changing your documents - but not in every state. In addition to reviewing your documents, you should also consider the assets that have beneficiaries to ensure that your former spouse is not named as a beneficiary on your retirement savings plan, life insurance, and other financial accounts. In the case of a new marriage, it is important you have a discussion with your new spouse about your assets entering into the marriage and your wishes as related to the distribution of those assets in the event of your death. In many cases, spouses enter into pre- or post-nuptial agreements to address estate inheritance issues and estate planning documents should reflect those agreements. Distance If you relocate from the state where your estate plan was created, it is important to have your estate planning documents reviewed by an attorney licensed in your new home state. Laws vary greatly from state to state with respect to rules of inheritance, asset protection, and estate taxes. While states do honor other states' documents under the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the US Constitution, each state has its own forms and provisions that may make a revision of your estate plan in the new state more practical and cost-effective in the future. In addition to your own move, if a fiduciary that you have named in your Health Care Proxy or Power of Attorney moves across the country it should be considered whether it is practical for that person, who now lives in a different time-zone, to continue in that role. It becomes even more complicated in the case of a fiduciary moving out of the United States. In New York for example, if you name a person as your executor who resides in a foreign country, it is unlikely the Court will honor your choice and instead appoint someone else as an executor. Descendants It is imperative to create an estate plan when you have children. In 2020, I generally do not have to remind clients that bad things happen. In the unfortunate event that you and your spouse or partner die with minor children, it is imperative that you make an election with respect to your children's care. A Will should provide a guardianship provision for your minor children in the event of your death. Leaving this information out of your Will or relying on a Will that was created before you became a parent could be catastrophic for your minor children. If you are a single parent, the importance of a Will with a guardianship clause is exponential. If you die without a guardianship provision, anyone in your child's life could petition the court for her guardianship. The court will decide guardianship based on your children's "best interests" - which might not match what you would believe to be in your children's best interests. In the case of a grandparent who excitedly amended her Will to include her first grandchild as a beneficiary, it is important that her estate plan is updated for each new grandchild. With all of this in mind, it is important to think of your estate plan as fluid. Whether it is a new presidential administration or one of the 5 D’s, it is so important to stay in touch with your estate planning attorney and review your estate plan to make sure it is reflective of your current life circumstances.
December 18, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Caught Between Generations: A Roadmap for the Challenges and Strategies of the Sandwich Generation
In the ever-changing landscape of family dynamics and related demographics, a term has emerged in the last few years to describe a group of people who find themselves literally squeezed between the demands of caring for and planning for aging parents and supporting their own children: “The Sandwich Generation.” Personally, finding myself in this unique group, alongside many of my friends, we face numerous challenges and responsibilities, requiring us to balance our caregiving roles for our aging parents and our children while maintaining our own well-being. In this article, we will delve into what the Sandwich Generation entails and offer insight into strategies for effectively managing these often-overwhelming responsibilities that characterize this unique phase of life. What is the Sandwich Generation?: The term “Sandwich Generation” refers to individuals who find themselves entwined in the middle of a generational “sandwich,” positioned between aging parents on one side and dependent (or semi-independent adult) children on the other. Those of us in the sandwich are literally stuck in between, managing both sides. Typically, the individuals who make up the Sandwich Generation are in their 40s to 60s, grappling with the dual responsibility of managing both ends of the generational spectrum. Still, with expanded life expectancy, varied family make-ups, and childbearing years stretching into the 5th decade, age alone does not define membership. The crux of what characterizes the Sandwich Generation is the simultaneous responsibility of providing care and support to both older and younger family members. Challenges The Sandwich Generation Faces: Financial: Navigating the dual responsibilities of supporting both aging parents and children can impose a significant financial burden. From medical expenses and long-term care costs for aging parents to education and upbringing expenses for children, the financial strain can be overwhelming. The strain is exacerbated by the fact that many aging parents do not have the resources or the aforethought to plan for the cost of care properly. Consequently, the onus falls to their adult children, the Sandwich Generation, to solve via their own financial means or provide the required care for their aging parents personally. Time: Members of the Sandwich Generation often find themselves juggling multiple roles and responsibilities. The delicate balance between the demands of caregiving, coupled with professional commitments and personal obligations, can lead to an intense time crunch, resulting in stress and guaranteed burnout. There are simply not enough hours in the day to help everyone in the way they need help. Emotional: Navigating the simultaneous care of aging parents and raising children can be emotionally taxing. Witnessing the decline of one’s parents while safeguarding the well-being of one’s children can lead to a cascade of feelings, including guilt, anxiety, depression, and emotional exhaustion. Throw in the addition of complicated relationships with those aging parents and siblings who have differing opinions on how one’s aging parents should be cared for, and it can be a recipe for emotional disaster. Lack of Support: Individuals grappling with Sandwich Generation challenges often experience a lack of support and resources tailored to their unique circumstances. Family members do not always live geographically near others, which can lead to feelings of resentment for those who can’t be there physically to offer support. Even worse is when family members are within close geographical proximity and still do not offer support, burdening one family member with the overwhelming responsibility of “doing it all.” Strategies for the Sandwich Generation: Foster Open Communication: Talk about it! It is crucial that you foster open and honest communication with your family members. Discuss your caregiving responsibilities and the areas where you need assistance with your spouse or partner, your children, and your parents. Ensuring everyone is aware of the challenges you face in providing care can help set realistic expectations and build a support network within your family. Seek External Support: The time to reach out for help is now! Whether the support is found in your community resources, support groups, or organizations that cater to the needs of the Sandwich Generation, external support is vital. It might be helpful to keep in mind that the community and support groups are free. Connecting with others facing similar challenges in the Sandwich Generation can provide insight, solutions, advice, practical assistance, exchange of information, or just an old-fashioned vent session. Prioritize Self-Care: We all know the anecdote that plane passengers hear at the start of every flight: put on your own oxygen mask first, and only then can you help others. This old adage is something easier said than done. The bottom line is that caring for others begins with caring for yourself. As a member of the Sandwich Generation, make it a priority to engage in self-care activities such as exercise, pursuing your favorite hobbies, and even practicing relaxation techniques. Maintaining your physical and mental well-being is essential to effectively providing care to those around you. Remember, you cannot effectively care for others if you are running on empty. Holistic Financial and Elder Care Planning: Work with a financial advisor, an elder law attorney, and a geriatric care manager to develop a comprehensive plan that considers the financial, legal, and emotional needs of both your parents and children. Explore potential benefits, government programs, legal documents, and long-term care options to alleviate the financial and legal strain. The time to plan is now. Delegation is Key: You simply cannot do it all. Do your best to identify tasks that can be delegated or shared among family members, friends, or hired professionals like those mentioned in number 4 above. You can even involve your children in age-appropriate caregiving responsibilities to assist their grandparents or take away some of your burdens so that your attention can turn to your aging parents. Do not hesitate to seek assistance from your siblings or other relatives to distribute the workload more evenly. Embracing delegation is crucial for maintaining balance and effectiveness in your caregiving role. Embrace the Power of Technology: Utilize technology to streamline caregiving tasks. Explore online scheduling tools, medication reminders, and telehealth services. Embracing technology can help save time, reduce stress, and improve efficiency in managing both your aging parents’ and your child’s care. Leverage technology to empower those far-away family members to contribute to caregiving by paying bills remotely, scheduling doctor appointments, or even ordering groceries online. Embracing technology ensures a more streamlined and collaborative approach to managing the care of both your aging parents and your children. For those of us who know, being a member of the Sandwich Generation can present numerous challenges. Still, navigating these responsibilities successfully with the right strategies and support is possible. The key is finding a balance between caregiving roles and your own well-being. While the role remains challenging, no matter how many solutions are identified, it is possible to thrive while supporting both the older and younger generations in your family. Click here to listen to my podcast, The Sandwich Generation Survival Guide.
December 5, 2023
Estates and Trusts
23 and Me (and who?) and your Estate Plan
Originally posted on 12/10/2022, content updated on 11/27/2023 With the holidays just around the corner, the advertisements for the home DNA test kits are everywhere: For only $99, give the gift of your family tree! In fact, a local restaurateur told me recently that one night he had two separate tables of families “meeting” both for the first time, after receiving their DNA results from one of these kits. Suffice it to say, the direct-to-consumer DNA test kits are adding an element of surprise to many family gatherings. Finding out about a long-lost half-sibling can be great news (or startling news,) but it can also throw an estate plan into chaos. In New York, as in many jurisdictions, estate planning attorneys like myself draft estate planning documents such as Wills and Trusts with language referring to one’s “issue”. In the legal world, a person’s issue is defined as children, grandchildren, and their lineal descendants – in short, the genetic line. Using a term like “issue” is common in estate planning documents so that a person’s lineal heirs are covered in one’s estate plan, even in the event of an untimely death of a younger-generation family member. For example, I might draft a Will that states: “I leave my entire estate to my surviving issue” – which in laymen’s terms means: I leave everything to my children and lineal descendants. Now, suppose your father, who was married to your mother for his adult life, fathered a child unbeknownst to him with someone other than your mother. You are contacted by this child via one of these genetic testing sites and told that you have been identified as their sibling through your father’s bloodline. In the meantime, your father dies with a Will that leaves his estate to his “issue”. Does this newly discovered sibling factor into your father’s estate plan? You bet he might. The path to prove heirship to a decedent in New York is often complicated and rarely direct. If Dad knew about the child and openly acknowledged his relationship, then it would be much easier. In these cases, the New York Courts have accepted an “openly acknowledged” child outside of a marriage as an heir, even without genetic testing. In the example of an “unknown” heir or a child that was never acknowledged, the court most often requires DNA testing to prove heirship, along with other evidence to prove the relationship. So far in New York, the courts have not accepted a self-administered DNA test as independently sufficient to prove heirship. Further DNA testing is required by an approved DNA testing lab to meet the New York standard. However, what is important to note is that an unknown heir obtaining information from a DNA home test kit, might be enough to convince a court to take a harder look at who are the children of the decedent. Preliminarily the results from a home DNA test kit could provide that child enough standing to halt any distribution of the estate until the matter can be further investigated and the child is provided an opportunity to prove his relation. As sophisticated science becomes more available to the general public, the law will inevitably change to accommodate the accessibility of this information, particularly as it relates to estate planning. So, if you find a DNA testing kit under the tree this year resulting in a surprise branch of your family tree, it might be important for you to meet with an estate planning attorney.
November 27, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Holiday Harmony (or Hubbub): Disinheriting with Finesse
Whether it is the result of a discussion about politics, a few too many after-dinner drinks, or a shift in a family relationship, after every major holiday, calls from clients increase requesting a change in their estate plan. Regardless if you wish to reconsider who shall serve as guardian for your minor children in the event of your death or to disinherit a family member, things change. The good news is that an estate plan is fluid, and if drafted properly, removing someone from your estate plan is not as complicated as one might assume. Where to start? First things first, you should not make this change to your Last Will and Testament on your own. In New York, defacing a Last Will and Testament, writing notes in the margin, or crossing out someone’s name is generally insufficient to change a Will. In the worst-case scenario, markings on a Will, or defacing it, could even revoke the entire Last Will and Testament, not just the portion you wish to change. Can you make a change? In a word, yes. Wills are revocable and amendable at any time before you die, as long as you have the requisite mental capacity to make this change. In fact, a Will is not an enforceable legal document until your death. And generally speaking, you can leave your assets to anyone you choose, whether they are related or not. Likewise, aside from certain protections for your spouse, you can disinherit almost any family member from your Will. In fact, other than the State of Louisiana, no state even requires that you leave assets to your adult children (minor children are entitled to support from your estate). The protections in place that will not allow you to disinherit your spouse entirely due to public policy reasons will be addressed in a future article. Similarly, with a change to a named guardian for your minor children, you may remove the named guardian from your Will at any time and replace them with someone you believe is more suited for the job. For single parents, it is important to note that naming someone other than the child’s surviving parent as guardian of the minor child is generally insufficient unless there are extenuating circumstances that would render the surviving parent an inappropriate guardian for your minor child. Why make a change? The most obvious reason people make changes to the beneficiaries of their Will is due to family conflict or estrangement. However, there are many other reasons that one may wish to consider making a change. It may be that your beneficiary was recently diagnosed with an illness and, due to that illness, may need to apply for means-tested government benefits. If that is the case, assets that you may leave to that person may be attached by his creditors, like Medicaid, or worse, the inheritance could disqualify him from a much-needed public benefit. One of your beneficiaries, who may have had a greater financial need when you created your Will, may no longer be in a dire financial situation and simply may not need the financial support. Alternatively, one of your beneficiaries may have shown themselves to be financially irresponsible with her own assets, and you may wish to reconsider leaving funds to someone who does not have the ability to properly manage those assets or set up a trust instead to direct how those funds can be used. Suppose one of your beneficiaries is going through a protracted divorce proceeding or is in a marriage that is likely to dissolve. In that case, you may want to reconsider leaving assets directly to that loved one, as the inheritance could end up with your beneficiary’s former spouse. In the case of making a change to your minor child’s guardian, there are all sorts of reasons to replace a guardian. The named guardian may not be as connected to your family or your child as she once was when the Will was first established. Perhaps the named guardian does not live geographically close to your family any longer, and you wish to consider a more local choice for your child to remain in the event of your death. Similarly, if the guardians you chose were married at the time you signed your Will but are married no longer or have had a significant change to their own lifestyle, they may not be the right choice as guardians of your minor children now. There may be a change in the guardian’s religious or political beliefs that are now quite different from your own and could influence how you would otherwise wish your children to be raised. Regardless of the reason for the change of heart, it is important that a change in guardianship be articulated in a properly executed Will; otherwise, such an appointment could be unenforceable, and a court would determine the best guardian for your child. How to make the change? It is important for you to contact an estate planning lawyer to make the above changes to ensure that they are effective. In addition, when making a change that could alter your entire estate plan, it is important that you communicate to the attorney drafting the change your reasons why the change is being made. In the event that one of the disinherited beneficiaries challenges your Will upon your death, the more information the lawyer has to support this change, the less likely a challenge by a disgruntled beneficiary would be successful in his challenge. For practical purposes, it is best practice to mention the related beneficiary who would otherwise inherit specifically in your Will. For example, when disinheriting an adult child or sibling, it is recommended that you include their name and state that “for reasons known to them” or “not for lack of love and affection,” they are not a beneficiary of the Will. This mention does two things. First, if the disinheritance is not for conflict or any other reason, it is a kind gesture to say so to ensure there are no misunderstandings about why you chose to disinherit them. The second reason why a mention of this person is important is so that the disinherited beneficiary cannot make a case to challenge the Will by saying there was a drafting error or they were unintentionally omitted. By the same token, if a person would not be otherwise entitled to inherit from you, in the example of a more distant family member, an in-law, or a friend, there is no reason to mention that they have been excluded from your Will. In conclusion. If your Thanksgiving holiday was full of more conflict than stuffing, contact our office, and we can provide you with the proper guidance to make a change. Similarly, if you are concerned that your current Will that already disinherits a family member could be challenged by him, you may wish to consider a trust that is harder for a disinherited family member to challenge. Either way, your estate plan is your own, and you have a right to ensure that those who inherit from you and those who serve as guardians for your minor children are the individuals that you choose.
November 17, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Discretionary Trust Distributions – When “Because I said so!” May Be Legally Sufficient
Not too long prior to Senator Diane Feinstein’s recent passing, her daughter, exercising a durable power of attorney (POA) for the ailing Senator, filed suit seeking to force payments by the trustee of what is described as a very generously endowed trust fund (by the Senator’s late billionaire husband) reported to include provisions to cover expenses related to the Senator’s health and welfare. So many directions to take this one! This single-sentence summary presents so many potentially valuable legal nuggets to mine! . . . from “What’s a durable POA?” to “What possible good-faith basis could the trustee have for refusing to pay/reimburse for medical/healthcare expenses with funds entrusted to his/her oversight for this very purpose?” I’ll leave the durability question to Siri and Google, noting that with the adoption in states such as Virginia of what is known as the Uniform Power of Attorney Act (or “UPOAA”), powers of attorney are now presumptively durable unless expressly indicated otherwise in the document itself. Before moving on, I’ll also add that a POA need not require the incapacity of its principal/maker to empower the agent/attorney-in-fact to act on the principal’s behalf. Many people mistakenly presume that a POA is intended only to take effect upon the incapacity or incapability of the principal to act on one’s own behalf. POAs can be immediately effective or “spring” into effect if and only when specifically defined events occur, which define the circumstances when the agent’s authority springs to life on behalf of the principal. Without conducting any sort of formal study on the subject, I am confident when I say that springing POAs are by far the exception to the norm. For now, at least, I address myself to the meatier issues stemming from the late Senator’s trustee’s alleged breach of fiduciary duties and general malfeasance. Asked for my opinion about this “obviously-in-the-wrong” trustee after news of the legal action broke (because no one would go to the trouble of filing suit if the allegations weren’t true, right!), I instinctively provided my standard go-to, why-everyone-hates-lawyers response: “It depends!” With little more than the headline as fodder for a good cocktail party debate, any substantial opinion must necessarily depend on so many variables that any other conclusion about the merits of such a case should be presumed fiction (with similar presumptions regarding anyone who would be willing to draw any definitive conclusions about the impropriety of the trustee’s actions, motives, etc. on such scant information). For starters, the outcome of any such case and claim(s) totally depends on the precise language of the trust document governing the specific situation and the scope and extent of the authority such language extends to the trustee. Because the “correct answer” is so driven by the fact-specific trust language, it is truly pointless to speculate on whether the trustee should or should not have paid the particular expenses in the Feinstein situation. It is also precisely why two or more seemingly identical cases can produce seemingly equally contrary results. It is not necessarily true that one judge or jury gets it exactly right while another gets it completely wrong. Nearly identical facts can produce widely disparate legally correct results for a myriad of reasons. [For a separate case study on this issue, check out my co-authored piece on two seemingly identical cases resolving disputed beneficiary designations in the context of divorce-related life insurance obligations: “Same facts . . . opposite results!”] All that having been said, it is not uncommon for such trusts to build in not only a certain level of discretion for the trustee to decide when it might be appropriate to pay and when a particular expense might be unreasonably “over the top” or simply unnecessary. With such built-in discretion, the trustee has effectively been entrusted by the maker of the trust to act in a manner as to reach the closest equivalent to what the maker himself or herself might have decided. Under these circumstances, the trustee is essentially in the right simply because they said so. A court will generally not seek to impose its discretion over that of the individual the now deceased trust maker trusted in the first instance to make what the trustee determines to be the best decision. With this outcome in mind, I commonly encounter provisions bestowing on trustees the ability, or even the requirement, that before releasing any funds from the trust for expenses seemingly word-for-word covered by the trust, the trustee consider and/or “take into account” other resources available to the beneficiary. In this way, the trustee is forced to exercise fiduciary responsibility not only to the current trust beneficiary but also to those who would stand to benefit from the trust after the current beneficiary has passed. Then again, it might very well be that the scope of such authority is less than clearly defined in the trust document or that a trustee with an axe to grind and/or a personal agenda contrary to that of the beneficiary (perhaps favoring future beneficiaries over the current beneficiary, for instance) is, indeed, acting in a manner inconsistent with the trustor’s original intent. In either case, a court order might be needed to provide appropriate “aid and direction” to the trustee or forcing the trustee to act in a manner not otherwise abusing the discretion afforded to the trustee. One simply cannot presume to conclude as much from a news report, nor should one draw conclusions regarding either the trustee or the one bringing such an action against a trustee without knowing all the relevant facts – or at least substantially more of them than might be reportable in a 60-second, news soundbite. In one rather extreme example, I encountered an example recently where a trustee was empowered to provide for the health and welfare of the beneficiary, but only out of trust income (no principal) and if and only if the beneficiary passed a monthly drug test, the cost of which could be paid out of the trust income, but consequently serve to reduce the amount to be paid to the beneficiary. Whether to bring and/or how to defend such an action requires appropriate legal experience, understanding, and, consequently, investigation and analysis of as much relevant information as can be gleaned both from what might be readily available and that which might take some digging to uncover. In my experience, whether one or more valid claims exist in such situations requires significant investigative and analytical time and should not be presumed either a simple or inexpensive process nor one which is likely to lead to an unimpeachable, singular conclusion. I have observed, advised, and/or been involved to varying degrees in numerous such disputes representing various perspectives with differing agendas (consider, for instance, how a second or third-generation, non-profit charitable organization set up as a contingent beneficiary might view as a wasteful fiduciary breach of duty any payouts by a trustee to current beneficiaries with substantial independent wealth and the means to pay their own expenses). I would welcome the opportunity to evaluate the possibility of assisting should you find yourself on one or the other side of such a situation (or perhaps as a drafting attorney seeking to minimize the chances of such a dispute down the road).
November 13, 2023
Estates and Trusts
A Gift from the IRS? A Holiday Miracle
The holidays are nearly upon us, and for many, this means holiday cheer, baking, and our endless gift lists. What should also come to mind is the “gift” that the IRS bestows upon all of us, which is the ability to make many gifts to our loved ones free of taxes, together with the benefits that accompany making those gifts. Below is a handy list of gifts that should be considered as we close out 2023. Annual exclusion gifts: In 2023, an individual can make annual gifts of up to $17,000 per recipient to an unlimited number of individuals free from any gift tax. Married couples can double this gift to $34,000 per recipient to an unlimited number of individuals. This benefit is called the “annual exclusion amount” because the gift is excluded from gift tax for the calendar year in which the gift is made. The annual exclusion is a “use it or lose it” benefit, meaning that your ability to gift for that year ends after the year has passed. Not only are annual exclusion gifts an effective way to pass wealth to family members and others, free from estate or gift taxes, but these gifts also have the added benefit of reducing the gift-giver’s taxable estate that would otherwise be subject to an estate tax upon his death. These annual exclusion gifts can be made “outright” and paid directly to the recipient to qualify for the annual exclusion. Certain gifts can even be made to the recipient in a trust if it is properly structured. Lifetime gifts: Gifts exceeding the annual exclusion amount are sometimes referred to as “lifetime gifts.” When “lifetime gifts” exceed the $17,000 or $34,000 annual exclusion amount in the case of a married couple, it reduces the federal estate tax exemption of the gift-giver. For example, the current federal estate tax exclusion is $12.9M for each person. This means that at the federal level, the gift-giver can either gift during their life or die with $12.9M. Therefore, if the gift-giver gifts $117,000 to a recipient in 2023, $17,000 of the gift will qualify for the annual exclusion amount for 2023. The remaining $100,000 gift will reduce the gift-giver’s lifetime estate tax exclusion by $100,000, thus reducing his available estate tax exclusion credit from $12.92M to $12.82M at death. The other benefit of making more significant lifetime gifts that exceed the annual exclusion amount is that it removes the value of the gifted assets from the gift-giver’s estate. Removing assets from the gift giver’s estate can be particularly useful when the gifted asset is expected to appreciate in the future. By gifting those highly appreciable assets out of the gift-giver’s estate now, the gift-giver’s estate will pay a reduced estate tax at their death. Lifetime gifts should be strongly considered at the present time as the federal estate tax exclusion of $12.92M is set to “sunset” at the end of 2025. This means the amount of assets you can die with that will not be subject to an estate tax will plummet from $12.92M free of estate tax to only approximately $6.8M free of estate tax. Therefore, making gifts now to take advantage of the current $12.92M estate tax exemption is something to consider. Charitable Giving: Most appreciate the many benefits of gift-giving to a favorite charity: it feels good to make a positive impact while simultaneously supporting a cause that is meaningful to the gift-giver. Many are unaware, however, that there are trusts that can be established to provide the gift-giver with an income stream, a tax break during the gift-giver’s life, and a gift to one’s favorite charity at death. A charitable remainder trust does just that: it allows the gift-giver to make a contribution to the trust for the charity while simultaneously providing a partial tax deduction for the gift and an income stream to the gift-giver or her loved ones. The tax deduction the gift-giver receives from funding a charitable remainder trust is based on the type of charitable remainder trust created. The deductions, depending on the type of charitable remainder trust, are then calculated by several factors, including the present value of the charity’s interest, the assets “donated” to the trust, how long the trust will likely remain and/or the annual “payout” rate to the income beneficiary. In addition to the present tax benefit enjoyed by the gift-giver, the gift-giver can also name herself or a loved one as the beneficiary of the present income stream from the assets donated to the trust. Based on how the trust is set up, the gift-giver (or nominated income beneficiary) can receive income annually, semi-annually, quarterly, or monthly. The IRS requires that the annual income stream must be at least 5% but no more than 50% of the trust’s assets. After the specified term of the trust or upon the death of the last income beneficiary, the remaining trust assets are then distributed to the designated charitable beneficiaries. The charitable beneficiary (or beneficiaries) can be public charities or private foundations. Moreover, the trustee can be provided the power to change the trust’s charitable beneficiary (or beneficiaries) during the lifetime of the trust, if necessary. Gifting can be an integral part of one’s estate plan. Gift planning, especially involving trusts, can be complex and highly individualized. It is crucial to consult a knowledgeable estate planning attorney to ensure that the gifts made are properly structured and comply with tax laws at the state and federal levels, especially as the tax laws change over time. Please get in touch with me directly to discuss these or other gift-giving options before the end of 2023.
October 30, 2023
The Practice of Law
Jury Duty for Lawyers: Are You In or Out?
Jury service is both a civic duty and a privilege. Yet, attorneys rarely serve on juries. To be clear, there is a difference between reporting for duty and actually serving on a jury. For those attorneys who might consider reporting for duty, some question the value of the experience. In the County of Fairfax, Virginia, where I live and practice law, attorneys, along with judges, “first responders,” and some others are among those afforded an exception to jury duty. Every so many years, the County sends out a questionnaire to confirm eligibility to serve. I recently received mine and faced again the question of whether to exercise my right to choose not to serve, i.e., whether to opt in or opt out of jury service. That’s right, jury duty is optional for lawyers! (Please tell me I’m not the only one seeing the irony?!) [For a glimpse into the result of my previous decision to “opt-in” for jury duty.] I certainly don’t begrudge anything to those attorneys that choose to exercise their legal right to “opt out” of jury duty. After all, why expend all the effort when not being allowed to serve on a jury is practically a foregone conclusion – especially for a litigation attorney such as myself (and many of my colleagues with whom I’ve debated the issue)? I recognize that it is highly likely I will have wasted a great deal of time and effort only to be sent away without having been part of the deliberative process and/or helping decide a winner and loser at trial. Be that as it may, for me, at least, opting in is my only option. Why? As I stated at the outset, jury service is both a civic duty and a privilege. Expectation of a “strike?” For at least one of the lawyers trying a case, allowing an attorney on the jury is likely to be a bad thing since a lawyer-juror may be more likely to recognize weaknesses in the evidence presentation, including evidentiary gaps leaving material questions unanswered, and less likely, perhaps, to be persuaded by legal rhetoric. For these reasons and countless others, I suppose, it is very likely that a lawyer reporting for jury duty will be stricken with one of the “strikes” afforded to each of the parties as part of the jury selection process and, consequently, equally unlikely that the lawyer would actually end up serving on a jury. Our system would fall apart completely if everyone measured and determined their level of input by the relative expected impact on the overall process. Just as a single vote is unlikely to tip the scales of an election either way, the potential significance of one’s individual involvement in the judicial process cannot be overstated. I simply refuse to accept that the measure by which we ought to decide in the first instance whether to participate in the process at all is the extent to which we believe that our individual input is likely to be outcome-determinative. Rather, our willingness to serve, to make ourselves available to serve, as impartial decision-makers willing to share our time for others ought to equate to the level we would hope others might share of themselves should we ever find ourselves in need of a jury of our peers. Impacting the process? Whether one wants to accept responsibility for the consequences of one’s inaction, one’s non-involvement in the jury selection process impacts the end results. If the presence of an attorney is likely to cause one or the other party to exercise one of their limited strikes to remove the attorney from the jury, the absence of that attorney must necessarily mean that a strike remains available to be used on someone else. In other words, the ultimate makeup of the jury is skewed by the absence of an attorney who could have reported for duty, even if only to be struck. By not participating, therefore, an attorney has, unintentionally or otherwise, impacted both the process and the results merely by one’s absence. Jury of one’s peers? One accused of a felony is entitled to have the matter heard and decided by a “jury of one’s peers.” In a jurisdiction such as Fairfax, where lawyers abound, a jury pool with no lawyers would reflect less than accurately the “peer group” from which one’s jury is to be drawn. Consider, for instance, a lawyer-defendant on trial for a murder she didn’t commit. What ought the makeup of a jury pool of her “peers” properly include, if not a lawyer or two? My involvement would not assure an attorney on the jury for this hypothetically wrongly accused lawyer-defendant, but participating to the extent I am able amounts to playing my part and doing at least what is within my power to do. What if . . .? Maybe I get contacted and told to report to the courthouse. Maybe I get assigned to a jury pool, and report to a courtroom where lawyers preparing to try a case will ask a bunch of questions and decide whether having me sit on their jury is a good or bad idea. Maybe I survive all the strikes, get seated on a jury panel, and, after hearing all of the evidence, find myself in a jury room with the rest of that same jury panel deciding the fate of an accused criminal or the potential civil liability of parties to a civil case. Maybe I get elected foreman because those non-lawyers on the jury believe the attorney among them knows best what to do and how best to do it. Maybe we convict; maybe we acquit … or maybe we decide that one neighbor’s fence should be moved a foot to the left because it was improperly installed on the next-door neighbor’s side of the property line. Maybe, as a litigator myself, it proves to be an invaluable learning experience from which I am able to hone my craft. Maybe I gain a better appreciation for how all those potential jurors feel the next time I am the one selecting a jury. Maybe I make it as far as the first round of strikes and am sent home. I can live with that! I acknowledge the unlikelihood of my getting impaneled to help decide a case. I accept at the outset that most attorneys selecting potential jurors for their case will not see the potential value in having me in their jury box. I understand that it would be wishful thinking to believe I might find myself as the difference maker persuading fellow jurors to consider evidence in a different light, helping tip the balance in a case with life-altering consequences for the parties. For my money, opting out of jury duty is akin to not buying a lottery ticket – you can’t win if you don’t play. The PowerBall jackpot recently surpassed $1.5 Billion without a winner. My chances of winning were as infinitesimal as the next guy’s, . . . but I bought a ticket anyway. I’ll be sure to tell you all about it if my jury lottery number gets called. (P.S. I’m not making the same promise if my PowerBall number comes up!)
October 19, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Every Woman For Herself
Originally posted on 1/6/2021, content updated on 10/18/2023 I read a statistic that stopped me in my tracks: women are four times as likely to be a widow than men are to be widowers. Anecdotally, most of us know that women tend to outlive their partners but the fact that it is four times as likely should give us all pause. It should also prompt us as women to make sure that we have our proverbial houses in order, especially as we begin a new and brighter year ahead. How does one ensure her house is in order? Start with a list. The list should identify the assets that she owns, what the value of those assets are, and how she owns those assets. What are your assets? For practical purposes and for this exercise, your assets should be considered anything that you own that has value. Most people understand that their real estate, bank, brokerage, and retirement accounts are considered assets, but there are other items that might not immediately come to mind when you consider assets. Collectibles, artwork, expensive jewelry, interests in business, intellectual property, digital assets, inheritances, and insurance policies are also assets and often have significant value. It is important that these not-so-obvious assets are identified. How do you own those assets? Assets can be owned in various ways: jointly with or without rights of survivorship, assigned percentages, in a trust, and solely are just a few examples. If you are married, you may own your primary residence together as “joint tenants with rights of survivorship” with your spouse. This means that if your spouse predeceases you, your home will pass to you by operation of law. If instead you own vacation property as tenants-in-common with your brother and he dies first, his share will pass to his own heirs – which might not be you. This is an important distinction because if you own property with your brother and his children are the heirs to his estate, his 50% ownership of the property will pass to them. If that is the case, his children may want to sell the property. Do you have the finances available to buy them out? Or do you want to own property with your brother’s children? Maybe. But maybe not. What is the value of your assets? Asset valuation is a moving target. The market value of real estate and equities fluctuate daily so asset valuation should be updated at minimum, on a yearly basis. Even more complicated is determining the value of business interests, intangible assets, and specific tangible personal property that may be unique in nature. Take for example an art collection: oftentimes it is necessary to engage an art expert qualified in that particular genre to determine the market value of a piece or an entire collection. Or, even more complicated, the valuation of a closely held business in which you are the sole proprietor: what the value is during your life may not be the same after you die. It may be necessary to engage an expert to evaluate the value of your role in a business with or without you. Why is it important to understand the value of your assets? In a word, taxes. Depending on the value of your assets and who you plan to leave your assets to when you die could mean the difference in hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes owed to the state or federal government upon your death, if not more. Knowing what your assets are worth will enable you to plan properly for who should inherit those assets and in what proportion. Beginning with a simple list is a good start in getting your own house in order; the list will better enable you to take the next step in planning. Knowing what you have will allow you to consult the appropriate professionals to create a functional estate plan that will serve your long-term goals and, in the end, protect you and your loved ones. After all, in the end, it is (four times as likely to be) every woman for herself.
October 18, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Have You Got the Power (of Attorney)?
Originally posted on 11/19/2020, content updated on 10/04/2023 The New York Durable Power of Attorney is an integral part of every estate plan, but it is also the one document that clients are most trepidatious about signing. Their concern is not unfounded. The Power of Attorney quite literally grants someone else the power to make decisions about another’s finances, property, business matters, taxes, gifts, investments and all things related. Why Do I need a Power of Attorney? Anyone over the age of 18 who has a bank account should have a Power of Attorney. If you own assets in your name, no one else can assist you in managing those assets if you cannot manage the assets yourself due to a short-term illness or incapacity, without a Power of Attorney. Many incorrectly presume that a spouse or family member can simply step-in and make any necessary financial transaction for another without a Power of Attorney in place; this is not the case. In fact, retirement assets, real property (even if owned jointly,) and solely-owned assets may not be accessed by anyone, including a spouse, unless she has a Power of Attorney signed by you, giving her permission to access those assets – even for simple tasks like paying bills. How Does the Power of Attorney Work? The Durable Power of Attorney allows you, the principal, to appoint another person, an agent, to make financial decisions for you. The decisions that you allow your agent to make can be tailored to your specific situation. Sounds easy, right? Not exactly. There is a tension that exists between giving your agents all the powers available under the law to act for you and very narrowly tailoring those powers to specific situations. Make the Power of Attorney too broad and your agent could step into your shoes and make any and all financial decisions on your behalf – decisions that you might not want another person to make for you. An overly restrictive Power of Attorney could very well leave your agent in a position where she cannot assist you in managing your assets in the way that you intended or in your best interest, rendering the Power of Attorney useless. Another important point is that Powers of Attorney are effective the moment you sign them, even prior to your incapacity. Practically speaking, your agent has the ability to use the Power of Attorney right away, which can be a worrying prospect. As such, it is vital that you choose someone who will act in your interest and not outside of the scope of what you intended. It should be noted that Powers of Attorney can be revoked at any time if the principal has the mental capacity to do so, and it is no longer effective upon the death of the principal. Who Should be your Power of Attorney? The who is the most important part of the Power of Attorney. Because your agent can be granted sweeping powers under your Power of Attorney if you allow it. She must be someone that you trust implicitly to make decisions based on the guidance you provided to the agent, and if you never gave direction, then the agent must act with your best interest in mind. Your agent should be responsible, honest and detail-oriented. The good news is that when New York State amended the law relating to the Power of Attorney in 2009 (and again in 2010,) it included the provision that the agent you appoint must also sign the Power of Attorney accepting your appointment of her and recognizing that she has a fiduciary obligation to the principal. The form explicitly advises the agent that in accepting the role, any transaction that she makes must be done in the best interest of the principal, not of the agent. The agent also has a fiduciary duty to keep receipts and documentation for transactions made under your Power of Attorney, never to co-mingle funds with theirs, and to avoid conflicts of interest. If your agent does not follow your wishes, or acts against your best interest, your agent could be held liable for violating the law. What Happens Without a Power of Attorney in Place? If you become incapacitated and you never got around to signing a Power of Attorney, or because you were too fearful of trusting someone as your agent, the only option is guardianship. A guardianship proceeding is a very serious legal process in which another party is required to appear in court and prove to a judge with medical evidence that you are not able to manage your own finances. The judge may appoint a family member, a friend, or a lawyer (whom you never met before) to take control of your finances. The court proceeding itself, while not only emotionally difficult for those involved, is quite expensive and should be avoided if at all possible. It is crucial that the option of a Power of Attorney be discussed with your estate planning lawyer. You should take great care in considering not only who should fill the role as agent, but also which powers you may wish to grant the agent.
October 4, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Handwritten Wills and the Couch Cushions that Hide Them
No doubt, the basic scenario plays out every day across America. An elder loved one passes, and an adult child or children are left to deal with an estate and no plan in place — or at least no apparent plan. What to do with mom’s comfy chair? How much is that old couch worth? Should we just donate everything to charity? Who decides? The oldest? The one living closest? Do we all get a vote? Before anything gets decided about the couch (or any other furniture, for that matter), I suggest everyone take a breath and consider the recent case of Aretha Franklin‘s four kids… and definitely don’t rush to divvy up everything and especially do not just get rid of the old couch! Nearly five years after the Queen of Soul passed and, no doubt, many tens (more likely hundreds) of thousands in legal fees later, the fate of Aretha Franklin’s estate was decided by a Michigan jury, which determined that a four-page “holographic“ (i.e., handwritten) document in a notebook found stuffed under Aretha‘s couch cushion was her intended last Will. No matter that the four kids had already long since mutually consented and arranged to have an agreeable cousin serve as a third-party neutral to administer the estate. No matter that the lack of a will had meant all four would share everything equally and that they’d come to terms with that. No matter that one of the four separate potential final will documents was several times longer, more detailed, found in a locked cabinet, and notarized! The jury’s findings result in Clarence Franklin getting cut out completely and brother Kecalf, alone, receiving Ms. Franklin’s $1.1 million home and most of her “personality” (i.e., her physical stuff-including jewelry, furs, and numerous luxury cars). Impossible to know for sure what Aretha had intended. In fact, according to a New York Times report, the trial judge overseeing the trial has ruled that portions of one or more of the earlier signed documents might still end up being incorporated into what the jury determined to be the final document. (Note: This can happen in certain circumstances when one deals more completely / thoroughly with the disposition of all that one owns in one document before creating another, which inexplicably makes no specific reference to replacing or substituting for the former document). So, despite having endured nearly five years of legal wrangling and a jury trial publicly airing the family’s “dirty laundry” along with matters preferably kept private, the Franklin kids may yet be forced to endure additional delays as the lawyers face-off on potentially unresolved issues, and Clarence and the other siblings now receiving substantially less than the presumed 25%, are now forced to consider their potential appellate options, as well. Why leave such unnecessary heartache to your loved ones after you’re gone? Consult a legal professional, and have it done correctly—and the way you want it—the first time. And if you have recently lost a loved one – especially if you’ve been led to believe they had an estate plan in place (and doubly especially if the “plan” they told you about appears to differ substantially from the plan the decedent actually left behind (or the lack of a plan altogether), I would urge you again to consider the plight of the Franklins and rethink that couch donation . . . at least until someone’s had a chance to lift the cushions and run their hands through the frame. (Epilogue: True, not-totally-unrelated, anecdote . . . I discovered a $20 bill and a pair of Ray-Ban® sunglasses (sold on the spot for $75) in the back of an abandoned couch acquired during a brief stint co-owning/operating a used furniture/carpet going concern more than 30 years ago. I didn’t have to become an estate and trust litigator to appreciate the potential treasure trove those old cushions might unlock! “What’s a ‘treasure trove?’” you ask . . . and “How does one determine ownership of a treasure trove when discovered?” That’s a whole other topic for another day. For now, happy couch-surfing!)
September 14, 2023
Estates and Trusts
What’s a Healthcare Proxy and Why Should You Have One?
Originally posted on 12/10/2020, content updated on 09/13/2023 It is vital to have a proper health care directive in place in the event you become sick and cannot independently advise your health care providers of your wishes. In 1991, the New York Health Care Proxy Law established the right for an adult to nominate another person to make medical decisions for her in the event she is unable to effectively communicate her wishes independently. The goals of establishing this standard in New York was to avoid confusion when a medical decision needed to be made for someone who could not do it herself, to identify the person who could communicate those wishes, to ensure the wishes would be carried out, and most importantly, to withdraw treatment when the proxy decides that it would not be something that the patient would want or that continued care is not in the patient’s best interests. How the Health Care Proxy Works The Health Care Proxy document only goes into effect when you are unable to effectively communicate your wishes to your health care providers. The proxy allows for the appointment of two people, referred to in the document as “agents”, in the order in which they are named. The order of the proxies in the document determines the order in which medical personnel will consult with them about decisions that need to be made about your health. Agents are not permitted to act together in New York because joint action could lead to disagreement, which of course undermines the purpose of the document. The medical decisions that an agent might make on your behalf can range from the most basic like the dispensing of antibiotics to the suspension of artificial ventilation which might end your life. The Health Care Proxy also provides instruction regarding organ and tissue donation in the event of your brain death. How to Choose Your Agents Your agent must be 18 years of age and does not have to be someone related to you. While it is true that many choose a family member like a spouse or an adult child for the agent role, there is no requirement that your agent be related to you. In fact, some choose a close friend or trusted advisor to fill the role of an agent so that a family member’s emotion does not factor into a health decision, particularly a decision that could end your life. Others nominate their religious advisor so that treatment is based on their faith’s doctrine to guide the medical decision. Regardless of the individual you choose, it is imperative when considering someone for the role that you nominate a person who will speak for you regarding the type of care that you would choose for yourself, if you could articulate your own wishes: this person should not substitute thier wishes for your wishes. Instead, you should choose an agent who understands your wishes as they relate to any and all health care decisions, including life-saving measures, and who will articulate those wishes to your health care providers. This person should be someone who understands and respects your feelings about living and about dying, and fully comprehends the quality of life that you wish to live. In addition, the person should be comfortable advocating for you with health care providers and dissenting family members alike. How to Communicate Your Wishes The discussions that you have with your agent are so important because this is the information she will rely on to make decisions for you if the need arises in the future. These discussions with your agent often evolve over time. Your feelings about living and dying and the type of care that you may want are oftentimes influenced by age, a life-limiting diagnosis or even someone else’s health crisis that you have witnessed. Verbal discussions had with a proxy are legally sufficient for the agent to make a decision regarding any and all of your medical care, but many individuals take it a step further and also put a Living Will in place to illustrate certain wishes in writing. In short, Living Wills are documents that explain your thoughts about medical care and heroic measures. Often Living Wills go into detail about “heroic measures” to sustain your life including artificial nutrition, hydration, and ventilation. It is important to note that Living Wills are not substitutes for Health Care Proxies in New York and should only be used to supplement information provided to the agent. Who Should Have a Copy It is necessary that your agent not only know that she was appointed by you, but that she also has a copy of the document itself. With the prevalent use of cellphones, it is commonly recommended that your agent take a photo of the Health Care Proxy under which she is nominated so that it is readily accessible in any emergent medical situation. You should also provide copies of your Health Care Proxy to any of your treating physicians for their records, in addition. Finally, it should be noted that, even if after reading this article, you never get around to completing a Health Care Proxy, all is not lost. New York State passed the Family Health Care Decisions Act (“FHCDA”) in 2010 that gives guidance on what to do if someone does not have a Health Care Proxy in place. The FHCDA allows for family members to act as your “surrogate” and make health care decisions for you, including decisions to withdraw life-sustaining treatment. However, you are not able to choose which family member will speak for you, so it is not a sufficient substitute for a Health Care Proxy.
September 13, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Estate Planning for Professional Athletes: The Playbook for Success on and off the Field
Professional athletes are no strangers to the limelight, but beyond the enthusiastic cheers of the fans lies the need for careful planning that extends far beyond their playing days. Estate planning can easily be forgotten amid the hustle and bustle of a rigorous training schedule and a busy sports season. In this article, we will delve into the unique considerations that professional athletes should consider when crafting a comprehensive estate plan. The Play: Understand the Game of Estate Planning Estate planning involves more than just the drafting of a Last Will and Testament. A proper estate plan creates an overall strategy to manage the professional athlete’s hard-won assets during their lifetime. A well-drafted plan also ensures a smooth transition of assets to the athlete’s loved ones in the event of an injury or following one’s death. As a professional athlete, income streams, investments, intellectual property, and property ownership are customarily quite complex. Over the course of one’s career, an athlete may move frequently, acquiring assets in different jurisdictions with different laws along the way. They may also experience significant and volatile swings in their financial outlook that necessitate a review of an estate plan more often than most. In addition, due to the dynamic lifestyle of the professional athlete, close relationships may also change rapidly. It is vital that the professional athlete collaborates with tax professionals, financial advisors, and estate planners who have experience in handling the ever-changing and unique planning needs of athletes. The Starting Lineup: Wills and Trusts A Last Will and Testament is certainly one of the cornerstones of an estate plan. Most understand that Wills can assist in outlining how assets are distributed upon death. What many do not know is that Wills can also designate guardians for minor children and appoint a trusted advisor as the executor to carry the terms of a Will. Trusts are an even more powerful tool for athletes. Trusts provide much-needed privacy, minimize taxes, and allow for tailored distribution of assets to beneficiaries over time. The benefits of a Trust are often critical for an athlete, particularly if they have young children or heirs who require financial guidance. The MVPs: Powers of Attorney and Healthcare Directives One of the most challenging hurdles that athletes must face is injuries. More than any client, creating advanced directives is of the utmost importance for professional athletes who may face injury more regularly than others. Designating an agent under a power of attorney ensures that a trusted person nominated by the professional athlete can manage the likely complicated financial affairs in the event of injury or incapacity. Likewise, healthcare directives outline medical preferences and can empower a chosen individual to make medical decisions on behalf of the injured athlete if they cannot do so Game Strategy: Tax The substantial earnings of professional athletes are often subject to high tax rates. Those tax rates vary from state to state and from year to year. Implementing a tax-efficient estate plan can help minimize the tax burden on the professional athlete and their heirs. A properly created estate plan must include strategies like lifetime gifting, charitable giving, and utilizing trusts to preserve a professional athlete’s wealth and legacy. Protecting A Legacy: Intellectual Property Considerations An athlete’s brand, image rights, and related intellectual property assets continue to generate income long after the playing days are over. Including provisions in an athlete’s estate plan that address how these assets are managed and protected is essential. Harnessing this intellectual property involves setting up corporate structures to handle licensing and endorsement deals and ensuring a stream of income for the athlete’s beneficiaries – all of which must be appropriately allocated in an athlete’s estate plan. Team Collaboration: The Agent, the Manager, The Accountant, and the Lawyer Just as winning championships requires teamwork, a successful estate plan relies on effective and regular communication and collaboration between various trusted professionals. A professional athlete’s manager, agent, financial advisor, accountant, and estate planning attorney should work in tandem to ensure that all aspects of a professional athlete’s overall plan align with their goals and protect their interests and their family’s interests for years to come. Revise the Playbook: The Moving Target of an Estate Plan The life of an athlete is dynamic on nearly every level, and their estate plan is no different. Major life events, such as marriages, divorces, birth of children, disability, or even the death of a loved one, require the professional athlete to constantly assess their estate plan playbook. Changes in an athlete’s home state or playing career can immediately impact their financial circumstances, which will accordingly warrant adjustments to their estate plan. Professional athletes must regularly review and update their estate plans to reflect their current situation, location, and aspirations. Professional athletes spend their careers preparing for the “big game” — an estate plan is no different, but it requires a different kind of strategy. It is not just about preserving wealth, fame, and fortune; it’s about securing a legacy, providing for an athlete’s loved ones, and ensuring their hard-earned assets are properly managed. By assembling a winning team of experts and crafting a comprehensive estate plan, professional athletes can confidently stride into the future, both on and off the field. If you are a professional athlete, a loved one, or a sports agent, please contact me so that together, we can ensure that the professional athlete’s legacy and loved ones are secure for years to come.
September 8, 2023
Estates and Trusts
Estate Planning
Are you one of the many Americans putting off preparing an estate plan? Do you have an estate plan that you have not updated in several years? The following are just three reasons that you should get your estate plan prepared or updated. CONTROL. By developing your own estate planning documents, including, but not limited to, a last will and testament, a power of attorney, and an advanced medical directive, you are the one deciding how things will be done, rather than the state. Absent estate planning documents, an individual cannot influence what happens after their death and must rely on a combination of the state and their family. Entities and/or individuals that may not know your wishes. INHERITANCE. Estate planning documents direct the disposition of an individual’s personal and real property, but when an individual dies without these documents in place, the state will make that determination for the individual. Real and personal property is divided up and given to individuals based upon the given state’s methodology of intestate succession—something that may look completely different to what an individual would have desired. An estate plan allows you to ensure that you are the one to direct who inherits what after you pass, rather than allowing the state to decide for you. BURIAL. The topic of death and burial can oftentimes be a difficult subject to discuss with our loved ones, but as a result, our loved ones may not always know how exactly we would like our burial to take place. Whether an individual wishes for their burial to be religious, a-religious, simple, elaborate, austere, celebrative, or something entirely different, these are important decisions that should be denoted in an individual’s estate plan to ensure that they are followed. Seek legal counsel to ensure that your interests are protected. If you have any questions about this or Estate Planning/Estate Litigation topics, please contact me at austin.hinel@offitkurman.com or (703) 745-1899.
August 15, 2023
Estates and Trusts
What’s New in Estate Planning? Notable Local Law Changes
D.C. Adopts the Uniform Electronic Wills Act: Electronic Wills in D.C. – it’s the law! . . but should it be? As of March 10, 2023, the “Uniform Electronic Wills Amendment Act of 2022” (Law 24-296) became effective in the District of Columbia. With it, D.C.’s pandemic-inspired, emergency legislation allowing virtual will signings was formally replaced with a new Chapter 9 of Title 18, known officially as the “Uniform Electronic Wills Act” (D.C. Code § 18-901, et seq.). With its adoption of the Act and making permanent the previously interim measure, D.C. joins only six other states and the U.S. Virgin Islands[1] to have adopted the Act and made the leap legalizing will signing without ever putting pen to paper, or for that matter, without ever involving a pen or paper.[2]. In the District, to be legally enforceable, one’s will no longer needs to have been physically signed or reduced to paper. With the appropriate software and/or application, one can now finalize a will with a few keystrokes. Of course, there are some parameters, and one should not presume to have met all the criteria merely by tapping out a document on one’s laptop without consulting the Act . . . and a good lawyer! Nevertheless, the new law certainly makes it easier to make a testamentary disposition of one’s assets, i.e., direct who gets what when you die. I am left questioning the tradeoff; however, with the Pandora’s box of fraud schemes, this development undoubtedly unleashes. You can now create and sign your Will electronically in the District of Columbia . . . but should you? There has been no shortage of debate over the years as to steps minimally appropriate to make a legally enforceable will. While varying across jurisdictions and with only limited exceptions, certain minimum requirements regarding one’s “soundness of mind,” witnesses, notarization, signatures and related representations, for instance (see, e.g., DC Code § 18-102, et seq. and Va. Code § 64.2-403, et seq.), have universally been intended to assure both genuineness of a document and accuracy of one’s testamentary intentions on a document which only becomes legally operative after the testator is dead. With the advent and development of electronic communications (email, facsimile, text messaging, and the like) and, in recent years, the ever-improving ability to sign (or affix an equally individualized electronic mark), send, and store one’s electronically signed documents increasingly securely, the legal acceptability and enforceability of electronic signatures have become unexceptionally commonplace. Moreover, with the recent lessons of a global pandemic, including a new-found appreciation for conducting one’s affairs from a distance, the ability to “get one’s affairs in order” remotely became, for many, a life-preserving necessity. Time may reveal better the extent to which the inability to e-sign estate planning documents “forced” COVID-19 victims and countless others to die intestate, an argument I’ve heard posited in favor of easing and expediting signature requirements to this extent. In the District, emergency legislation made it possible, on a limited temporary basis, to execute wills without all of the “whistles and bells” otherwise required under the law. The primary argument for maintaining the physical signature requirement for wills, along with the physical presence of witnesses, generally centers on the significance of the finality of making testamentary disposition of one’s assets and not being around to assure that one’s intentions are carried out as we had intended. But with the general acceptance nowadays of e-signing in the context of so many acceptable alternatives to disposing of one’s assets without either invoking a will (trusts and contractual-based, third-party provider agreements such as life insurance and ERISA-qualified retirement plans, for instance) and/or the probate process pursuant to which one’s Will’s directions are administered and overseen, why should will-signing retain such an exceptionally high bar?. . or so the argument goes! With the advent of AI-generated, at times seemingly indifferentiable virtual “reality,” do we really need to ask “why?” Perhaps there will come a time when one’s “John Hancock” indelibly inscribed, notarially certified, and appropriately witnessed will no longer have any value at all. Perhaps. We’re not there yet, however, . . . at least not everywhere. Neither Virginia nor Maryland has yet to succumb to this latest modern trend towards allowing and trusting electronically signed will documents . . . although, it seems only fair to acknowledge in this regard that Virginia, for instance, has allowed exceptions to its strict signing/witnessing requirements in certain limited circumstances. [For more on “de facto wills” and the “Harmless Error Rule” in the Commonwealth, see my prior discussion regarding Virginia’s modified version of Section 2-503 of the Uniform Probate Code, Va. Code § 64.2-404.] Mind you, I am not suggesting that electronic evidence of a Will (including, for instance, a PDF copy of the purported Will itself) would not, per se, be devoid of probative value. By way of example, not too long ago, I found myself challenging whether an emailed copy of a document purporting to be a Will might itself be deemed a “de facto will” under Section 64.2-404 and the extent to which, if admitted into evidence, the electronic version of the document and the email transmitting it ought to be given weight by the judge when considering the decedent’s intended finality of the document at the time. Perhaps someday Virginia will fall lockstep into line in the march towards what may be an inevitably paperless, impersonal future. Maybe someday, sure, but I would take the “over” if anyone proposes a near-term adoption of such a risky proposition here in the Old Dominion. As of this writing, at least, D.C. stands alone in the “DMV” and with only a handful of other jurisdictions (in the mid- to Pacific West) formally allowing this dangerous practice. Over the years, I have counseled countless clients who have found themselves questioning the bona fides of a suspicious Will document or the circumstances and timing of the document’s creation. With what I perceive as the floodgates now opening, I suspect the next wave of litigation will involve many new variations on the theme requiring us to (dis)prove testamentary intent and whether certain 0’s and 1’s amount to an electronic signature of an improperly formatted, electronic document very loosely resembling what only some might consider a Will. You know where to find me! ___________________________________________________________________ [1] North Dakota and Washington enacted versions of the Act in 2021, and the U.S. Virgin Islands followed suit in 2022. D.C. joins Minnesota, Idaho, and Utah in enacting the Act in 2023, while Texas, Missouri, and New Jersey have introduced, but, as of this writing, have not enacted the Act. (Source: Uniform Law Commission, https://www.uniformlaws.org/committees/community-home?CommunityKey=a0a16f19-97a8-4f86-afc1-b1c0e051fc71, site visited on 8/8/2023) [2] Maryland has not adopted the Act but has adopted its own version of electronic will signing/witnessing. See Estates & Trusts §4-101, et seq. (Source: Maryland General Assembly, https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/Laws/StatuteText?article=get§ion=4-101, site visited on 8/29/2023.) There may be other states that have gone this route as well.
August 14, 2023