Estates and Trusts
Michael Jackson’s Inheritance Battle: Could Your Kids Face the Same Problem?
By Candace Dellacona
Even though Michael Jackson died seventeen years ago, the trust he set up for his children still has not been funded with any of the assets he left for them. Michael’s daughter, Paris, recently filed suit in California and asked a judge to order $600 million from Jackson’s estate to fund it and to obtain some transparency as to the fees that the now sole executor has collected along the way.
While most families will never have an estate that generates millions, and in Jackson’s case, billions, the question at the heart of this case is the same one often heard from families: where's their inheritance, and why is it taking so long?
The Jackson controversy is a high-profile lesson in what happens when the estate plan, the executor or trustee entrusted to effectuate the plan after your loved one’s death, and the beneficiaries are not on the same page.
It is important to distinguish between the “estate” and the “trust.” The estate is often defined as all of the assets held by the decedent at the time of passing. Often, assets in the “estate” are then distributed to trusts set up prior to, or upon the decedent’s death, which means that the trusts do not have assets in them until the executor of the estate hands them over to the trust or to the beneficiaries directly. In the Jackson estate, the Michael Jackson Family Trust was created in Jackson’s estate plan to hold and manage the Jackson kids’ inheritance upon his death. In court filings, Paris rightfully points out that the trust has sat unfunded for more than 17 years, meanwhile the money is still sitting in the estate and has earned billions in that time. Paris, along with her siblings, have also demanded information as to the commissions paid to the executor, particularly since so many of his reporting requirements have allegedly been breached.
The executor of Jackson’s estate is lawyer John Branca, who is no stranger to litigation. In fact, Jackson’s mother Katherine, also filed suit against Branca for what she described as a “secret” catalogue deal of her son’s works; the suit was later dismissed. With respect to Paris’s filing, Branca has maintained that he cannot fund the trust because of the unresolved IRS $700 million claim in taxes and related penalties.
While the value may not match most estate disputes, the theme of the Jackson controversy does: an estate executor — who says he is doing his best to act cautiously and with the duty of care to which he is obligated under the law — and the beneficiaries who are waiting, sometimes years, for their inheritance and insight into the fees paid to the fiduciaries of the estate are at odds.
It is important to note that an estate fiduciary (in the Jackson estate the executor is Branca) has to be careful about distributing assets too early in the estate administration process. If an estate fiduciary leaves the estate without sufficient assets to cover its obligations or makes distributions improperly, they can end up personally on the hook. Often, the delay is the single most frustrating issue and coming in as a close second, is the lack of transparency related to the estate process and the fees collected by the estate fiduciary, particularly in estates like Jackson’s that have on-going business interests, property to be sold, pending lawsuits and creditor claims.
Branca’s position is that he is holding back the funding of the trust for a “reserve” of funds to pay the IRS. For a more straightforward estate, the reserve is often a modest cushion held back until the taxing authorities close out the case or creditors’ claims are resolved. For an estate in litigation with taxing authorities and a huge sum of money at stake, such as the Jackson estate, the reserve can be enormous and the wait years long.
For those estates of more modest means, there are tools that can mitigate the delay and speed up the process. An executor can request that the taxing authority “expedite” its review and release the executor from personal liability by issuing a tax closing letter, which ends the taxing authority’s ability to go back and claim additional tax due. Additionally, having beneficiaries sign releases which includes language that states the beneficiary will promise to return money distributed to them if a tax bill comes later.
With so many cautionary tales, it is important that families strongly consider who they appoint as their estate executor or trustee, because the chosen fiduciary and their ability to properly manage the estate can have a significant and long-lasting impact on the family left behind.
Talking through the following questions can help clients choose an executor or trustee.
Does your family know and trust this person?
A brilliant professional your family does not know can feel like an unfeeling gatekeeper. On the other hand, a family member may feel familiar but lack the skills, the judgement, or the distance, to do the job well.
Should there be more than one fiduciary?
Co-executors and co-trustees, such as a professional paired with a family member, can balance expertise and care. While professionals do get paid, having a skilled professional at the helm, along with the family member or friend who knows the beneficiaries on a personal level, offers a balanced approach and is often well worth the cost to avoid litigation.
Who has oversight?
A trust “protector” is a person who can replace a fiduciary and provide the family an alternate path away from litigation if the relationship between the executor, the trustee, and the family breaks down. Trust protectors are less common in states like New York but can be appointed as an extra stop-gap, if you are worried about litigious family members.
How long will the job last?
A plan that keeps assets in trust for decades requires a responsible fiduciary and a succession plan built for the long haul. Ensuring that your documents indicate how successor fiduciaries are appointed is imperative, as is a non-judicial contingency in the event those you have named can no longer serve.
If you are the adult child of aging parents:
- Ask your parents who they have named as executor and trustee, whether that person knows they have been appointed, and if they are up for the job.
- Ensure you know where the physical documents are located, and who their lawyer and accountant are.
- If you are the named executor or trustee, inquire now what the job involves, including the assets and debts your parents have and how much liquidity you might need for taxes and debt when the time comes.
If you are the parent planning for your own kids:
- Review your fiduciary choices. Would your children trust that person, and is there an explanation on how to replace them included in your document that excludes judicial intervention?
- Build in reporting requirements so your kids will not have to petition the court to get information.
- Talk to your children about how the plan works. You do not need to share your total net worth but sharing the why can go a long way.
The court will take up Paris Jackson's request next month and the fight will surely continue into 2027. Whoever prevails, the lesson for the rest of us is already clear: an estate plan is more than who inherits, it is also about who is in charge, how long your family will wait to receive their inheritance and whether or not your family understands the “why” of it all.
