Intellectual Property

The Other AI Copyright Claim: How YouTubers Are Bypassing the Fair Use Debate

November 2, 2026

By W. Drew Kastner, Edward Baxter, Stephenie Wingyuen Yeung 楊穎苑, and LuAnne Morrow

The Other AI Copyright Claim: How YouTubers Are Bypassing the Fair Use Debate

On October 2, 2026, a Northern California District Judge denied Chinese AI giant ByteDance’smotion to dismiss in Ted Entertainment, Inc. v. ByteDance Inc., a class action by several YouTube content creators who allege their videos were scraped to train ByteDance’s text-to-video models, MagicVideo and Seedance. The case is unusual because it pleads no copyright infringement claim at all. The sole count arises under Section 1201(a) of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which prohibits circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to a copyrighted work. That framing sidesteps the fair use debate over AI training and asks a narrower question about how the videos were obtained. The plaintiffs allege ByteDance’s researchers downloaded videos directly from YouTube, bypassing the video platform’s protective measures.

ByteDance raised two defenses. First, it argued the plaintiffs lacked standing because their harms flow from copying and training rather than from circumvention, and because the private right of action belongs to the owner of the measure, which is YouTube. Second, it argued that videos free to watch cannot be “access controlled,” since YouTube’s measures only restrict copying. The court disagreed on each point and found the lost per-view advertising revenue traceable to circumvention, since scraped retrievals register no views. It held that copyright owners are squarely within the class Congress authorized to sue. On the merits, the court relied on the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Disney v. VidAngel for the principle that one measure can serve as both an access control and a copy control. Since the plaintiffs allege that proof-of-origin tokens are required even to stream a video, the court found it plausible that these measures control access at the outset. The court adopted the view that these barriers may be modest, but they remain barriers.

This ruling adds to a growing line of decisions treating platform security as a legal protection that travels with the creator’s content, and the same plaintiffs have filed parallel suits against several other major technology companies. For creators, studios, and brands that publish online, the practical point is how and where you distribute your work shapes the claims available to you later. Choosing platforms with real access controls, keeping records of the revenue tied to views, and writing license terms that prohibit bulk extraction can each support a claim that does not depend on winning the fair use argument over AI training.

Firm Highlights

  • Events
    The 2026 Economic, Tax, and Accounting Updates
    We are looking forward to the Mid-Atlantic CFO Roundtable's next event on November 13, 2026. This is a program with topics built for Finance Executives. We are extremely fortunate to have three excellent speakers: Dr. Daraius Irani, Vice President of Business and Public Engagement at Towson University; Mike Stankus, Tax Office Managing Principal at BDO; and Daniel Wahlberg, Managing Partner of Acclare Solutions. The economy is rapidly changing with various factors driving it. The November 3rd midterm elections may also have an impact. Our three expert presenters will discuss the ramifications of the election, and the current year updates to GAAP financial reporting and Federal and State income taxes. Please join us for what will surely be an informative and timely discussion. Meet Our Speakers: Daraius Irani, Ph.D. • Towson University Vice President, Business & Public Engagement Dr. Daraius Irani serves as Vice President of Business and Public Engagement at Towson University as well as the chief economist for the Regional Economic Studies Institute (RESI) at Towson University, a policy group providing economic, fiscal impact, and policy analysis to public and private entities.  Dr. Irani is often called upon to provide economic presentations to organizations across Maryland. He has appeared on numerous television programs and in local and regional print media. Dr. Irani holds a Ph.D. in economics from University of California, Santa Barbara. Dan Wahlberg • Acclare Solutions Managing Partner With over 28 years of experience, Dan Wahlberg is a recognized leader in audit and assurance for the Mid-Atlantic’s middle market business community. As a licensed CPA in Maryland and Virginia, Dan has led assurance practices at top regional firms, including serving as Baltimore Audit Managing Partner and Assurance Practice Leader at BDO USA in Baltimore and as Partner and member of the Management Committee at Hertzbach & Company P.A which merged into BDO in 2020. His expertise centers on delivering clarity, strategic guidance, and proactive solutions to middle-market businesses across Baltimore and beyond. His entrepreneurial spirit has led him to begin a new CPA firm this year with four other CPAs serving the business community. Dan holds a Bachelor of Science in Accounting from Rutgers University and began his career at PWC in New York. He is also deeply engaged in the community, previously serving as President of ACG Maryland and current Board member and as Audit Committee Member for The Associated: Jewish Federation of Baltimore.  Mike Stankus • BDO USA LLP Tax Office Managing Principal Mike Stankus is the Tax Office Managing Principal for the firm’s Baltimore office. He has more than 16 years of experience providing tax planning and preparation and management advisory services for his clients. Mike focuses on advising privately held businesses and their owners on effective growth and tax strategies. He also performs various engagements for mergers and acquisitions and complex cost accounting projects and projections. In addition, he represents various government contracting clients before the DCAA and assists with FAR compliance. Mike’s areas of concentration include working with government contractors, professional service firms, construction companies, and homebuilders.