Environmental and Sustainability
When Can You Challenge an NJDEP AONOCAPA Despite Missing the Hearing Deadline?
By Matthew Karmel
Missing the deadline to request an administrative hearing on an NJDEP AONOCAPA has serious consequences. In general, failure to submit a timely hearing request causes the enforcement action to become final and eliminates the opportunity to challenge the alleged violations or penalty.
But New Jersey courts have recognized that a late hearing request may still proceed in very limited circumstances.
Substantial Compliance Can Sometimes Excuse a Late Filing
In D.R. Horton, Inc. v. NJDEP, the company received an $18,000 penalty assessment and had 20 days to request a hearing.
The company mailed its hearing request by certified mail four days before the deadline, but the Postal Service did not deliver it to NJDEP until two days after the deadline. NJDEP denied the hearing request as untimely.
The Appellate Division reversed. It held that the doctrine of substantial compliance could apply where the company had taken reasonable steps to comply with the deadline and the late receipt resulted from circumstances outside its control.
The court considered factors including whether NJDEP was prejudiced, what steps the company took to comply, whether the purpose of the deadline was generally satisfied, whether NJDEP received reasonable notice, and whether there was a reasonable explanation for the late filing.
Not Every Late Request Qualifies
The result was very different in NJDEP v. Mazza & Sons, Inc.
There, the AONOCAPA expressly stated that a hearing request had to be received within 20 days and that the order would become final if no timely request was submitted. The company failed to request a hearing within that period and later attempted to challenge the enforcement action after it had become final.
The Appellate Division rejected the challenge.
The distinction is significant. D.R. Horton involved a company that acted before the deadline and narrowly missed it because of delivery delay. Mazza involved a failure to timely invoke the hearing process at all.
A more recent published decision, Musconetcong Watershed Association v. NJDEP, likewise cited D.R. Horton in concluding that receipt of a hearing request one day after the deadline did not automatically bar consideration of the request.
A court evaluating this will consider several factors to determine whether the party requesting the hearing achieved “substantial compliance” with the deadline, which is a fact-specific inquiry.
Nonetheless, a company may still be able to negotiate penalties and compliance with NJDEP even if they have technically waived their right to a hearing request. Still, missing a hearing deadline puts a company at a serious disadvantage given the inherent waiver of the right to formally challenge the AONOCAPA. As a result, negotiation following a missed deadline requires a specific approach.
Visit our NJDEP Enforcement Insights page for additional guidance, updates, and resources.
