Eric Lanter

Counsel

Commercial Litigation

Five Things to Take into Consideration When Negotiating and Settling a Case

January 22, 2025

By Eric Lanter

Five Things to Take into Consideration When Negotiating and Settling a Case

Settling a case is hard. Negotiating the terms and coming to an agreement can take weeks or months. But once the parties agree to the general terms of a settlement (e.g., the amount of money changing hands and the timing of the settlement payment), there are a number of other considerations for putting the settlement agreement in writing. Here are five things to know when you are negotiating to settle your case:

You Can Protect Your Privacy

Even though the documents filed in the lawsuit will remain public, the settlement details don’t have to be public. One effective tactic is to separate the settlement agreement from the “stipulation of discontinuance.” This allows the terms in the settlement agreement to remain private, with the only document being filed with the court simply stating that the parties have agreed to discontinue the case.

You Can Set the Rules for After the Lawsuit

A settlement agreement can also be useful for clarifying what the parties can and cannot do after the lawsuit. Often, parties agree to include a provision in the settlement agreement requiring the parties to keep the settlement terms confidential and not to disclose those terms to anyone. Some parties may even agree to a non-disparagement provision, requiring them to refrain from saying anything negative about each other. Although these are provisions that often can be overlooked when negotiating a settlement, they can help to permanently put the dispute to rest and assist the parties with moving past the lawsuit.

Plan for What Happens if Someone Breaches the Agreement

You may be feeling optimistic that you are finally settling your case. Not so fast. Contemplate what may happen if something still goes wrong: what if the settlement payment doesn’t come through? Or what if someone breaches some other part of the agreement? The settlement agreement should provide a roadmap for what happens next. You may want to include whether the breach of the agreement goes back to the court you were in or whether the dispute goes to arbitration. You also may want to have a provision stating that if the other side breaches the agreement, you are entitled to additional damages and that the other side has to compensate you for your attorneys’ fees. Including these terms in the agreement can save you resources and avoid the frustration of going back to court if the other side breaches.

Don’t Overcomplicate It

Lawsuits are stressful. Don’t add to that stress by making the settlement more complicated than it needs to be. Include the terms you need to wrap up the case and exclude those other terms that often don’t apply to your case or that you don’t need. Prioritize being clear with the terms you include, as sometimes a settlement agreement can go on for dozens of pages when just a fraction of that can suffice.

Once You Sign, the Settlement is Final

Before you sign a settlement agreement, make sure you understand each piece of the agreement. If you don’t understand some portion of the agreement, you may be taking on obligations you don’t know about or waiving rights that leave you worse off. Settling a case requires careful attention to detail, and drafting a settlement agreement that clearly reflects the parties’ intentions is critical to avoiding future disputes. By addressing these key considerations in your negotiations, you can ensure the settlement process is effective and that your interests are protected.

Related People

Related Services

  • Biography
  • Representative Matters
  • Publications & News
  • Blog Posts
  • Featured Works

Firm Highlights

  • Events
    The 2026 Economic, Tax, and Accounting Updates
    We are looking forward to the Mid-Atlantic CFO Roundtable's next event on November 13, 2026. This is a program with topics built for Finance Executives. We are extremely fortunate to have three excellent speakers: Dr. Daraius Irani, Vice President of Business and Public Engagement at Towson University; Mike Stankus, Tax Office Managing Principal at BDO; and Daniel Wahlberg, Managing Partner of Acclare Solutions. The economy is rapidly changing with various factors driving it. The November 3rd midterm elections may also have an impact. Our three expert presenters will discuss the ramifications of the election, and the current year updates to GAAP financial reporting and Federal and State income taxes. Please join us for what will surely be an informative and timely discussion. Meet Our Speakers: Daraius Irani, Ph.D. • Towson University Vice President, Business & Public Engagement Dr. Daraius Irani serves as Vice President of Business and Public Engagement at Towson University as well as the chief economist for the Regional Economic Studies Institute (RESI) at Towson University, a policy group providing economic, fiscal impact, and policy analysis to public and private entities.  Dr. Irani is often called upon to provide economic presentations to organizations across Maryland. He has appeared on numerous television programs and in local and regional print media. Dr. Irani holds a Ph.D. in economics from University of California, Santa Barbara. Dan Wahlberg • Acclare Solutions Managing Partner With over 28 years of experience, Dan Wahlberg is a recognized leader in audit and assurance for the Mid-Atlantic’s middle market business community. As a licensed CPA in Maryland and Virginia, Dan has led assurance practices at top regional firms, including serving as Baltimore Audit Managing Partner and Assurance Practice Leader at BDO USA in Baltimore and as Partner and member of the Management Committee at Hertzbach & Company P.A which merged into BDO in 2020. His expertise centers on delivering clarity, strategic guidance, and proactive solutions to middle-market businesses across Baltimore and beyond. His entrepreneurial spirit has led him to begin a new CPA firm this year with four other CPAs serving the business community. Dan holds a Bachelor of Science in Accounting from Rutgers University and began his career at PWC in New York. He is also deeply engaged in the community, previously serving as President of ACG Maryland and current Board member and as Audit Committee Member for The Associated: Jewish Federation of Baltimore.  Mike Stankus • BDO USA LLP Tax Office Managing Principal Mike Stankus is the Tax Office Managing Principal for the firm’s Baltimore office. He has more than 16 years of experience providing tax planning and preparation and management advisory services for his clients. Mike focuses on advising privately held businesses and their owners on effective growth and tax strategies. He also performs various engagements for mergers and acquisitions and complex cost accounting projects and projections. In addition, he represents various government contracting clients before the DCAA and assists with FAR compliance. Mike’s areas of concentration include working with government contractors, professional service firms, construction companies, and homebuilders.
  • Events
    AIA Tri-State Conference
    Princeton will serve as the backdrop for three days of connection, learning, and design leadership. From keynotes to tours to the Tri-State Design Awards, this year’s conference is designed to go far beyond education sessions. Kick off the week with pre-conference intensives and individual state component Design Award celebrations, followed by three days of education, inspiration, networking, and design excellence at the 2026 AIA Tri-State Conference—featuring pre-conference intensives, three keynote speakers, 25 education sessions, curated tours, an expo, spec academies, and the AIA Tri-State Design Awards—bringing together architects and design professionals from New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania to connect, learn, and celebrate the best of the profession. G2. Designing Secure Practices: Cybersecurity, Data Privacy, Contractual Provisions, and Insurance Risks for Architects (4:00 PM - 5:30 PM) Architects and design professionals increasingly rely on cloud platforms, BIM software, and digital tools to manage sensitive data, creating cybersecurity and privacy risks. A single incident can trigger liability claims, regulatory obligations, reputational harm, and insurance challenges. Yet many firms underestimate how contracts, insurance, and internal practices intersect during a breach. This program offers legal and insurance perspectives on cyber risk in architecture, examining liability exposure, risky contract provisions, and mitigation strategies. A cyber insurance expert will explain policy responses, coverage gaps, coordination with professional liability, and best practices for aligning insurance with contractual risk and protecting firms from evolving cyber threats. Learning Objectives: Identify key cybersecurity and data privacy risks faced by architecture firms and explain how these risks can impact professional liability and project outcomes. Analyze common contractual provisions to determine which clauses may increase exposure to cyber incidents and propose strategies to mitigate these risks. Evaluate the scope and limitations of cyber insurance policies, including coordination with professional liability coverage, to determine how a policy would respond in a breach scenario. Develop actionable risk management strategies by integrating legal, contractual, and insurance considerations to protect sensitive client and project data.