Two recent cases in Virginia are illustrative of some of the issues following the 2015 landmark United States Supreme Court case of Obergefell v. Hodges, which opened the door for same-sex marriages in every state in this country.
In Appel v. Celia, a trial court decided that Virginia’s assisted conception law is discriminatory as currently written. The law reads that only a husband (not spouse) of a woman who gives birth from assisted conception (such as IVF) is presumed to be the child’s parent.
The trial court decided it could either declare the law null and void or extend the benefits of the law to same-sex marriages. Looking to what other states have done with similar laws and the intent of the legislature, the trial court ordered the benefits of the law must be extended to same-sex marriages.
While Appel v. Celia, showed a seemingly progressive move by the Commonwealth, Hawkins v. Grese, decided just five days after Appel v. Celia, and came out quite differently.
In Hawkins v. Grese, two women were in a long-term relationship and Grese had a baby in 2007, during the relationship. The couple never married, never had a civil union, and Hawkins never adopted the baby. The two women raised the child together until the relationship ended in 2014. A few years later, Grese ended all contact between the child and Hawkins.
After moving through the court system, the Virginia appeals court (one step higher than the trial court) rejected the argument that the Obergefell decision meant the women’s relationship was the equivalent of marriage and Hawkins was “constitutionally” a parent because of Obergefell.
Perhaps more relevant to future cases, the Virginia Court of Appeals failed to consider whether Obergefell had any retroactive application as the women’s relationship both started and ended before the 2015 Obergefell decision and stated that is a “question which has not yet been answered.”
In the upcoming months and years, it will be interesting to find out if this is a question the Virginia courts will ever answer.
Questions on this topic or any other family law issues? Contact Elizabeth Szabo at firstname.lastname@example.org or
ABOUT ELIZABETH SZABO
Elizabeth C. Szabo focuses her practice on family law. Before transitioning to family law, Ms. Szabo was a civil and commercial litigation attorney in Northern Virginia. She has been an adjunct professor in the Legal Research & Writing Program at The George Washington University Law School since 2013 and, in addition, has been a repeated member of the teaching staff of The George Washington Graduate School of Education & Human Development since 2009. Ms. Szabo is admitted to practice in Virginia and is a member of the Family Law section of the Virginia State Bar.
Ms. Szabo received a Bachelor of Arts degree from Boston College in May 2005, where she graduated magna cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa. She graduated from The George Washington University Law School in 2009, with honors.
ABOUT OFFIT KURMAN
Offit Kurman is one of the fastest-growing, full-service law firms in the Mid-Atlantic region. With over 150 attorneys offering a comprehensive range of services in virtually every legal category, the firm is well positioned to meet the needs of dynamic businesses and the people who own and operate them. Our eleven offices serve individual and corporate clients in the Virginia, Washington, DC, Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and New York City regions. At Offit Kurman, we are our clients’ most trusted legal advisors, professionals who help maximize and protect business value and personal wealth. In every interaction, we consistently maintain our clients’ confidence by remaining focused on furthering their objectives and achieving their goals in an efficient manner. Trust, knowledge, confidence—in a partner, that’s perfect.
You can connect with Offit Kurman via our Blog, Facebook, Twitter, Google+, YouTube, and LinkedIn pages. You can also sign up to receive Law Matters, Offit Kurman’s monthly newsletter covering a diverse selection of legal and corporate thought leadership content.
MARYLAND | PENNSYLVANIA | VIRGINIA| NEW JERSEY | NEW YORK | DELAWARE | WASHINGTON, DC