Legal Blog
Handcuffs or Rocket Booster?
Crafting Joint Venture Agreements that Launch Your Business Forward
Print Article | Download Article
July 2014
Businesses team up to pursue work all the time. These joint ventures take many forms and names, from teaming agreements, to partnership agreements, to more formal contracts such as limited liability company operating agreements. These agreements usually address — with varying degrees of success — the activities surrounding the attempt to win the work. But joint ventures all too often share common and critical flaws. Most notably, they often fail to effectively tackle how you will work together if you win the job.
Why the lack of advance planning for important functions? Why do otherwise bright businesspeople run before they can walk? Easy answer: they’re in a hurry. They are so eager to win the prize, they’re focused on the competition to win, not the problems and complexities of working together if they succeed and get the job.
The Fine Print
It may be a brilliant move to team up with another business. Or it could all be a disaster.
The risks are many. You could get cut out of the deal or receive far less work than you expected. In fact, one of the most common complaints of smaller businesses that team up with larger companies is that the little company only receives a few crumbs, while the big business takes the cake. Of course, the victims here jumped in without a fair and effective agreement with their teammates. Instead, they got fuzzy promises about the work they would receive — and little or nothing in writing. It takes a lot of foresight and discipline to nail down, in advance, exactly how you will divide the work, and price it, if and when you win the job. But that’s not what often happens. Everyone is busy working 24/7 to prepare the proposal, and they don’t have time to tackle or insist upon a formal joint venture agreement. So even if the “team” is victorious, that leaves many small businesses stuck with lower prices for their work or work that generates less profit, often on a take-it-or-leave-it basis.
If you do succeed in establishing a joint venture agreement that equitably allocates and prices each partner’s share of the job, you still face the potential for considerable problems. For example, what happens when one partner does not perform and threatens to drag down the entire joint venture? This could not only cost you the contract, it could expose you to a lawsuit and paying out damages for another partner’s misdeeds. All too often, partners fail to plan for the teammate that does not carry its weight. In one case, the two partners were being jeopardized by the poor performance of their third partner. But the group had cobbled together their own sketchy joint venture agreement and failed to reserve the right to expel a nonperforming partner. Even though the two partners proved, at an arbitration, that the third business was constantly understaffing the job and jeopardizing the contract, the arbitrator refused to expel this company because the partners had never agreed that any of them could be kicked out of the joint venture.
Control is also a big issue. The bigger the project, the more likely one of the partners will be a large company that has gone to the trouble of preparing its own agreement. Sometimes this agreement is a subcontract dressed up to look like a joint venture agreement. That is, the large company is really acting as a prime contractor, and your company will be its subcontractor. The prime contractor will have considerable, if not complete, control and your rights will be limited at best.
Where a group of companies with similar size and/or bargaining power are involved, there are often greater attempts at shared control. Yet these agreements can also present plenty of problems because it is complicated to share control. There are no simple answers. Sometimes it is appropriate to give each partner a degree of control over their areas of expertise, then require majority votes for other decision making. Other times, you need one strong boss or, alternatively, a board of directors to run the show. The solution to these and other problems depends on each situation.
Plan Ahead
Still, there is at least one plan that will solve a lot of these problems. If you are going to pursue joint ventures on a regular basis, create your own agreement so that you will have it ready when you’re rushing to form a team and win the work. If you have an agreement that provides for the likely situations and problems you will face, then you are in a position to insist that the group adopt your agreement — of course, with their reasonable changes — rather than just proceed on a handshake and hope.
When you craft your joint venture agreement, you will need to address a variety of issues. Consider the following checklist:
- What type of entity will you pick for your joint venture?
- Who’s in charge, how will you share control and who votes on what?
- Who gets what work, and how is it priced?
- How are profits distributed and when? What type of cash reserve will you maintain?
- Can you get rid of a partner? If so, when and how?
- How do you fund the joint venture, and can you require the partners to chip in more money later in a “cash call”?
- Does the joint venture restrict any of the partners from separately competing for other business?
- If you introduced the customer to the group, are your partners prohibited from doing other business with that customer? Likewise, are your partners prohibited from poaching your employees?
- If one of your partners breaks the law — for example, by bribing the customer — must they indemnify you, including paying your legal expenses?
- If you have a dispute, will you go to court or arbitration, and will the loser pay the winner’s legal fees?
This is already a long list. But it’s just a fraction of the issues you need to address in an effective joint venture agreement. Most folks don’t bother. But businesses that have been burned by a bad agreement — or no agreement at all — understand the considerable risks of leaving these issues to chance. Yes, a joint venture can be a handcuff or a rocket-booster. But a good agreement is much more likely to launch your business.
Jack Garson is the author of How to Build a Business and Sell It for Millions (St. Martin’s Press) and writes a business law column called The Legal Edge for SmartCEO Magazine. As founder of the law firm Garson Law LLC, he leads the business and real estate practice groups. Jack serves as a legal advisor for numerous local, regional and national companies, focusing on business transactions, commercial real estate and construction law. In addition to providing legal counsel, he services as a strategic advisor and negotiator for many clients, providing guidance on issues such as the growth and sale of businesses, liability and risk reduction, the hiring and retention of key personnel, and protecting and enhancing profitability, as well as negotiating the resolution of complex commercial disputes. Jack has been selected to be included in The Best Lawyers of America and he has repeatedly received the Super Lawyer designation. He has been recognized as a DC region Legal Elite and has received a Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rating of “AV” since 1995, representing the highest possible ratings for legal ability and ethical standards.
- Accidental Crook: A Guide to Handling Almost Any Legal Snafu, The Huffington Post
- Beware The Claw-backs from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Big Brother from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Contracting Gone Wild from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Data Duties from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Desperate Measures: The Disastrous Consequences of Business Shortcuts, SmartCEO Magazine
- Don’t Take ‘No’ for an Answer: Tips for Going Straight to the Top to Resolve Problems, The Huffington Post
- Five Hidden Company Killers, The Huffington Post
- Five Legal Myths That Can Cost You a Fortune, The Huffington Post
- Franchise Club from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Handcuffs or Rocket Booster? Crafting Joint Venture Agreements that Launch Your Business Forward, The Huffington Post
- Hit by the Bus from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- How to Build the $100 Million Business
- I Got You Covered: Ensuring Your Business Has Insurance When You Need It, The Huffington Post
- Jumpstarting Growth from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Killer Contract Clauses – Creating a Winning Contract, The Huffington Post
- My Lawyer, My Friend: A CEO’s Guide to Working with an Attorney, The Huffington Post
- On the Edge: How to Establish and Protect Your Competitive Advantage
- Protect Your Bargains from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Pick Your Partners from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Read the Contract: I Rushed, I Signed, I Regretted, The Huffington Post
- Riches to Rags: The Bungee-Jumping Entrepreneur, The Huffington Post
- Shark or Bait? At Risk in the Shark Tank
- Show Me the Money from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Talking with Steve Monroe: Recessionary Counsel
- The New Norm: Crazy Contracts: How to Fight Back, The Huffington Post
- Think Before You Type from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- When to Pull the Plug on Your Business, The Huffington Post
- Why Business Partnerships Go Bad, The Huffington Post
- You’re Building a Business — But Can You Sell It?, The Huffington Post
- A Developer’s Life: Not What It Used To Be
- Avoid Money Pits Before Sinking Cash into a Property
- Commercial Real Estate in 2014: Taking Down the Cranes
- Construction Success
- Contractor vs. Employee from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- In the Spotlight: Beware of Lease Disputes in a Declining Market
- In the Spotlight: Construction of Improvements to Premises
- In the Spotlight: Planning for Redevelopment
- Mall Renovations: The Price of Beauty
- Multi-Family Trends: Accessibility Requirements Command Attention
- Nailing the Lease: Tenants Enjoying the Ride
- Are You Pregnant from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Beware The Claw-backs from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Big Brother from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Brave New Whorl from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Business Smarts: Poster Perfect
- Contractor vs. Employee from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Driven to Distraction from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Five Hidden Company Killers, The Huffington Post
- How to Get Sued by Your Employees — Let Me Count the Ways, The Huffington Post
- I Got You Covered: Ensuring You Have Insurance When You Need It, The Huffington Post
- Interviewing Do’s and Disasters, The Huffington Post
- New Media, New Rules from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Sub or Scrub: Why to Keep a Close Eye on Your Contractors, The Huffington Post
- Viewpoint: Employment Law Run Amok, Washington Business Journal
- Wage Law Woes from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- When 401(k)s Attack from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Brave New Whorl from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Fantasy Law from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Five Legal Myths That Can Cost You a Fortune, The Huffington Post
- New Media, New Rules from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- War on the Internet from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Arbitration Alternative from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Battling Behemoths, from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Five Legal Myths That Can Cost You a Fortune, The Huffington Post
- To Court or Not to Court, The Huffington Post
- A Developer’s Life: Not What It Used To Be
- Avoid Money Pits Before Sinking Cash into a Property
- Ball and Chain from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Be Prepared: Bad Tenants Happen to Good Landlords
- Commercial Real Estate in 2014: Taking Down the Cranes
- Customizing Your Lease: One Size Fits All?
- For Tenants That May Expand Later, There Are Options
- For Tenants, What You Know Before You Negotiate is Key
- How to Get a Lower Rent
- How to Get Out of a Bad Lease, The Huffington Post
- In the Spotlight: Assignment and Subletting Provisions Rock Your World
- In the Spotlight: Beware of Lease Disputes in a Declining Market
- In the Spotlight: Beware of Real Estate ‘Icebergs’
- In the Spotlight: But for an Option, the Kingdom Was Lost
- In the Spotlight: ‘Da Insurance Code’
- In the Spotlight: Lease Commencement: Getting the Ball Rolling
- In the Spotlight: Navigating the CAM Minefield
- In the Spotlight: Planning for Redevelopment
- In the Spotlight: The Bad Broker Provision
- In the Spotlight: Unenforceable Lease Provisions
- In Selling a Building Don’t Let a Big Payday Slip Out the Door
- Keeping it Real: Tenants Start Enjoying the Ride Again
- Key to a Good Lease is not in the Deal, but in the Details
- Nailing the Lease: Tenants Enjoying the Ride
- Renter Prepare: What Went Down May Be Going Up
- The Myth of the National Credit Tenant
- The Perils of Exclusivity
- The Simple Use Clause: Complex Problems Caused by a Simple Provision
- To Buy or Not to Buy from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- You May Feel Trapped in a Lease, But Escape Routes Exist
- You’re Ready to Sell Your Firm, But is Your Lease Ready?
- Accidental Crook: A Guide to Handling Almost Any Legal Snafu, The Huffington Post
- Contractor vs. Employee from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Data Duties from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Five Hidden Company Killers, The Huffington Post
- Franchise Club from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Handcuffs or Rocket Booster? Crafting Joint Venture Agreements that Launch Your Business Forward, The Huffington Post
- Hit by the Bus from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- How to Build the $100 Million Business
- How to Get Sued by Your Employees — Let Me Count the Ways, The Huffington Post
- I Got You Covered: Ensuring Your Business Has Insurance When You Need It, The Huffington Post
- Interviewing Do’s and Disasters, The Huffington Post
- Jumpstarting Growth from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Killer Contract Clauses – Creating a Winning Contract, The Huffington Post
- My Lawyer, My Friend: A CEO’s Guide to Working with an Attorney, The Huffington Post
- On the Edge: How to Establish and Protect Your Competitive Advantage, SmartCEO Magazine
- Pick Your Partners from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Read the Contract: I Rushed, I Signed, I Regretted, The Huffington Post
- Riches to Rags: The Bungee-Jumping Entrepreneur, The Huffington Post
- Shark or Bait? At Risk in the Shark Tank
- Show Me the Money from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- The New Norm: Crazy Contracts: How to Fight Back, The Huffington Post
- Think Before You Type from The Legal Edge, SmartCEO Magazine
- Why Business Partnerships Go Bad, The Huffington Post
- You’re Building a Business — But Can You Sell It?, The Huffington Post

Jack Garson
(240) 507-1744
jack.garson@offitkurman.com